Click here to download

Democracy in chains: civilization, slavery and war in J. S. Mill and Karl Marx’s writings on America.
Author/s: David Ragazzoni 
Year:  2014 Issue: Language: Italian 
Pages:  20 Pg. 475-494 FullText PDF:  71 KB
DOI:  10.3280/SF2014-003004
(DOI is like a bar code for intellectual property: to have more infomation:  clicca qui   and here 

Both living in London for more than twenty years (1849- 1873), Karl Marx and J.S. Mill commented extensively on the features and contradictions of American society and politics. In particular, the two thinkers devoted a substantial number of letters, articles and systematic writings to the issue of slavery and to the events of the Civil War at the beginning of the 1860s. The literature has never compared their philosophical-political questionings of post-Tocquevillian America, nor has it investigated the continuities in and ruptures between their analyses of the slavery-based American economy and society. Consequently, the author focuses specifically on their American writings in an attempt to cast light on some significant similarities between the two philosophers when addressing their European readers on the American Civil War and the central issue of slavery. Although embedded within different moral and political languages, their understandings of slavery pursued a twin goal: to reveal how relevant the categories of "race" and "class" vis-à-vis State sovereignty and the development of modern democracy had become since Tocqueville, and to point out the very close linkage between the American events and the fate of Europe as far as labour movements were concerned. From such a perspective, in the author’s view, they urged their European readers to go beyond the military façade of the Civil War and develop a broader theoretical perspective on what was really at stake on the other side of the Atlantic.
Keywords: Mill (John Stuart), Marx (Karl), slavery, American Civil War, civilization, despotism, revolution

  1. - Anderson 2010: Kevin B. Anderson, Marx at the Margins. On Nationalism, Ethnicity and Non-Western Societies, The University of Chicago Press, Chicago-London 2010.
  2. - Bell 2010: Duncan Bell, John Stuart Mill on Colonies, «Political Theory», XXXVIII, 2010, 1, pp. 34-64.
  3. - Berlin 1939: Isaiah Berlin, Karl Marx. His Life and Environment, Oxford University Press, London-New York 1939.
  4. - Bolognesi, Mattarelli 2008: Dante Bolognesi, Sauro Mattarelli (a cura di), Fra libertà e democrazia. L’eredità di Tocqueville e di J. S. Mill, Angeli, Milano 2008.
  5. - Catanorchi, Ragazzoni 2010: Olivia Catanorchi, David Ragazzoni (a cura di), Il destino della democrazia. Attualità di Tocqueville, prefazione di Michele Ciliberto, Edizioni di Storia e Letteratura, Roma 2010.
  6. - Collini 1984: Stefan Collini, Introduction, in John Stuart Mill, Collected Works, vol. XXI, Essays on Equality, Law and Education, ed. by John M. Robson, University of Toronto Press-Routledge and Keagan Paul, Toronto-London 1984, vii-lvi.
  7. - Duncan 1973: Graeme Duncan, Marx and Mill. Two Views of Social Conflict and Social Harmony, Cambridge University Press, London-New York 1973.
  8. - Emerson 1962: Ralph Waldo Emerson, Antologia degli scritti politici di Ralph Waldo Emerson, a cura di Antonio Santucci, il Mulino, Bologna 1962. - Feuer 1963: Lewis S. Feuer, The North American Origin of Marx’s Socialism, «The Western Political Quarterly», XVI (1963), 1, pp. 53-67.
  9. - Galli 2004: Carlo Galli, Ordine politico e guerra civile tra America ed Europa, in Tiziano Bonazzi – Carlo Galli (a cura di), La Guerra Civile americana vista dall’Europa, il Mulino, Bologna 2004, pp. 7-25.
  10. - Ginsborg 2006: Paul Ginsborg, La democrazia che non c’è, Einaudi, Torino 2006.
  11. - Goldberg 2005: David T. Goldberg, Liberalism’s Limits: Carlyle and Mill on “The Negro Question”, in Utilitarianism and Empire, ed. by Bart Schultz and Georgios Varouxakis, Lexington Books, Lanham 2005, pp. 125-136.
  12. - Hall 1989: Catherine Hall, The Economy of Intellectual Prestige: Thomas Carlyle, John Stuart Mill and the Case of Governor Eyre, «Cultural Critique», XII (1989), pp. 167-196.
  13. - Hegel 1961: Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel, Lezioni sulla filosofia della storia, traduzione di Guido Calogero e Corrado Fatta, vol. I, La Nuova Italia, Firenze 1961.
  14. - Herreshoff 1967: David Herreshoff, American Disciples of Marx: From the Age of Jackson to the Progressive Era, Wayne State University Press, Detroit 1967.
  15. - Hosfeld 2013: Rolf Hosfeld, Karl Marx. An Intellectual Biography, Berghahn Books, New York-Oxford 2013.
  16. - Jahn 2005: Beate Jahn, Barbarian thoughts: imperialism in the philosophy of John Stuart Mill, «Review of International Studies», XXXI, 2005, pp. 599-618.
  17. - Kahan 1992: Alan S. Kahan, Aristocratic Liberalism. The Social and Political Thought of Jacob Burkhardt, John Stuart Mill and Alexis de Tocqueville, Oxford University Press, Oxford 1992.
  18. - Kohn, O’Neil 2006: Margaret Kohn, Daniel I. O’Neill, A Tale of Two Indias: Burke and Mill on Empire and Slavery in the West Indies and Americas, «Political Theory»,
  19. XXXIV, 2006, 2, pp. 199-228. - Levin 2004: Michael Levin, J. S. Mill on Civilization and Barbarism, Routledge, London 2004.
  20. - Losurdo 1988: Domenico Losurdo, Hegel, Marx e la tradizione liberale: libertà, uguaglianza, Stato, Editori Riuniti, Roma 1988.
  21. - Losurdo 2005: Domenico Losurdo, Controstoria del liberalismo, Laterza, Roma-Bari 2005
  22. - Marx, Engels 1953: Karl Marx, Friedrich Engels, Letters to Americans: 1848-1895.
  23. A Selection, ed. by Alexander Trachtenberg, New York, International Publishers, 1953.
  24. - Marx 1964: Karl Marx, Il Capitale, trad. di Delio Cantimori, Editori Riuniti, Roma 1964.
  25. - Marx, Engels 1971: Karl Marx, Friedrich Engels, De America 1°. La guerra civile, a cura di Enrico Forni, Silva, Roma 1971.
  26. - Marx, Engels 1973: Karl Marx, Friedrich Engels, La guerra civile negli Stati Uniti d’America, Del Bosco, Roma 1973.
  27. - Marx, Engels 1976: Karl Marx / Friedrich Engels Collected Works, vol. VI, Progress Publishers-Lawrence and Wishart-International Publishers, Moscow-London-New York 1976.
  28. - Marx-Engels 1984: Karl Marx / Friedrich Engels Collected Works, vol. XIX, Progress Publishers-Lawrence and Wishart-International Publishers, Moscow-London-New York 1984.
  29. - Mehring 1953: Franz Mehring, Vita di Marx, Edizioni Rinascita, Roma 1953.
  30. - Merker 2010: Nicolao Merker, Karl Marx. Vita e opere, Laterza, Roma-Bari 2010. - Mill 1946: John Stuart Mill, Considerazioni sul governo rappresentativo, a cura di Pietro Crespi, Bompiani, Milano 1946.
  31. - Mill 1984a: John Stuart Mill, The Negro Question in Id., Collected Works, vol. XXI, Essays on Equality, Law and Education, ed. by John M. Robson, University of Toronto Press-Routledge and Keagan Paul, Toronto-London, 1984, pp. 85-96.
  32. - Mill 1984b: John Stuart Mill, The Slave Power in Id., Collected Works, vol. XXI, Essays on Equality, Law and Education, ed. by John M. Robson, University of Toronto Press-Routledge and Keagan Paul, Toronto-London, 1984, pp. 145-164.
  33. - Mill 2005: John Stuart Mill, L’America e la democrazia, a cura di Pietro Adamo, Bompiani, Milano 2005, pp. 497-499.
  34. - Morais 1948: Herbert M. Morais, Marx and Engels on America, in Samuel Bernstein (ed. by), A Centenary of Marxism, Science and Society, New York 1948, pp. 3-21.
  35. - Nimtz 2003: August H. Nimtz, Jr., Marx, Tocqueville, and Race in America. The “Absolute Democracy” or “Defiled Republic”, Lexington Books, Lanham 2003.
  36. - Nippel 2005: Wilfried Nippel, Marx, Weber, and Classical Slavery, «Classics Ireland », XII (2005), pp. 31-49.
  37. - Parekh 1995: Bhikhu Parekh, Liberalism and colonialism: a critique of Locke and Mill, in The Decolonization of Imagination: Culture, Knowledge and Power, ed. By Jan Nederveen Pieterse and Bhikhu Parekh, Zed Books, London 1995, pp. 81-98.
  38. - Petrucciani, Trincia 1992: Stefano Petrucciani, Francesco S. Trincia (a cura di), Marx in America. Individuo, etica, scelte razionali, Editori Riuniti, Roma 1992.
  39. - Petrucciani 1995: Stefano Petrucciani, Marx al tramonto del secolo. Teoria critica tra passato e futuro, Manifesto Libri, Roma 1995.
  40. - Petrucciani 2012: Stefano Petrucciani, A lezione da Marx. Nuove interpretazioni, Manifesto Libri, Roma 2012.
  41. - Ragazzoni 2010: David Ragazzoni, Educare la democrazia: Mill lettore (o discepolo?) di Tocqueville, in Catanorchi-Ragazzoni 2010, pp. 231-254.
  42. - Ragazzoni 2012: David Ragazzoni, Metamorfosi dispotiche del governo rappresentativo e dell’homo democraticus. Ripensare la nostra “democrazia dei moderni” attraverso Ciliberto, Ferrajoli e Urbinati, «Ragion Pratica», 38/giugno 2012, pp. 277-295.
  43. - Ragazzoni 2013a: David Ragazzoni, Pluralismo, conflitto, giudizio. Appunti per rivertebrare la “democrazia dei moderni”, «Fenomenologia e società», XXXIV, 1/2013, pp. 111-121.
  44. - Ragazzoni 2013b: David Ragazzoni, Carl Schmitt e Hans Kelsen: il problema della rappresentanza, «Rivista di filosofia», CIV, 1, aprile 2013, pp. 51-76.
  45. - Ragazzoni 2014: David Ragazzoni, Democrazia: fenomenologia di un disagio, genealogia di un’idea, «Archivio di storia della cultura», XXVII (in uscita nel 2014).
  46. - Robinson 1983: Cedric J. Robinson, Black Marxism: The Making of the Black Radical Tradition, University of North Carolina Press, London 1983.
  47. - Robson 1998: John Robson, Civilization and culture as moral concepts, in The Cambridge Companion to Mill, ed. by John Skorupski, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1998, pp. 338-371.
  48. - Rubel 1967: Maximilien Rubel, Marx and American Democracy, in Nicholas Lobkowicz (ed. by), Marx and the Western World, University of Notre Dame Press, Notre Dame 1967, pp. 217-228.
  49. - Runkle 1964: Gerard Runkle, Karl Marx and the American Civil War, «Comparative Studies in Society and History», VI (1964), 2, pp. 117-141.
  50. - Salvadori 2005: Massimo L. Salvadori, L’Europa degli Americani. Dai Padri fondatori a Roosevelt, Laterza, Roma-Bari 2005. - Smits 2007: Katherine Smits, John Stuart Mill on the Antipodes: Settler Violence against Indigenous Peoples and the Legitimacy of Colonial Rule, «Australian Journal of Politics and History», LI, 2007, 1, pp. 1-15.
  51. - Tocqueville 2007: Alexis de Tocqueville, La democrazia in America, a cura di Giorgio Candeloro, Biblioteca Universale Rizzoli, Milano 2007.
  52. - Tunick 2006: Mark Tunick, Tolerant Imperialism: John Stuart Mill’s Defense of British Rule in India, «The Review of Politics», LXVIII, 2006, pp. 586-611.
  53. - Urbinati 2007: Nadia Urbinati, The Many Heads of the Hydra: J. S. Mill on Despotism, in Nadia Urbinati, Alex Zakaras (eds.), J. S. Mill’s Political Thought: A Bicentennial Reassessment, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2007, pp. 66-97.
  54. - Urbinati 2010: Nadia Urbinati, Individualismo democratico. Emerson, Dewey e la cultura politica americana, Donzelli, Roma 2010.
  55. - Varouxakis 1997: Georgios Varouxakis, John Stuart Mill on Intervention and Non-Intervention, «Millenium: Journal of International Studies», XXVI, 1997, 1, pp. 57-76.
  56. - Varouxakis 2005: Georgios Varouxakis, Empire, Race, Euro-centrism: John Stuart Mill and His Critics, in Utilitarianism and Empire, ed. by Bart Schultz and Georgios Varouxakis, Lexington Books, Lanham 2005, pp. 137-154.
  57. - Weiner 1980: Robert Weiner, Karl Marx’s Vision of America: A Biographical and Bibliographical Sketch, «The Review of Politics», XLII (1980), pp. 465-503.

David Ragazzoni, Democracy in chains: civilization, slavery and war in J. S. Mill and Karl Marx’s writings on America. in "RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA" 3/2014, pp. 475-494, DOI:10.3280/SF2014-003004


FrancoAngeli is a member of Publishers International Linking Association a not for profit orgasnization wich runs the CrossRef service, enabing links to and from online scholarly content