Clicca qui per scaricare

Religious Freedom and the Quest for a new Creed. Herbert Spencer’s religious Thought in Context
Titolo Rivista: RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA 
Autori/Curatori: Federico Morganti 
Anno di pubblicazione:  2016 Fascicolo: Lingua: Inglese 
Numero pagine:  22 P. 47-68 Dimensione file:  576 KB
DOI:  10.3280/SF2016-001003
Il DOI è il codice a barre della proprietà intellettuale: per saperne di più:  clicca qui   qui 


Religious freedom and the quest for a new creed. Herbert Spencer’s religious thought in context. The present article is an attempt to contextualize Herbert Spencer’s religious thought, as outlined in the first part of his First Principles (1862) under the title of The Unknowable. Following the most recent scholarship, Spencer’s doctrine of the Unknowable is accounted for by reference to the need for a New Reformation advocated in the early 1850s by the radical weekly The Leader. The Author argues that Spencer’s emphasis on religious freedom was motivated by the necessity for a new creed which was to be neither dogmatically religious nor purely scientific, while being broad enough to harmonize not only all religious faiths but also science and religion. It is suggested that for Spencer the cultural circle of The Leader proved not only to be a source of ideas on religious matters, but also a stimulating instance of the beneficial effects which a free discussion of even radical opinions could exercise on the intellectual development of society. Finally, after a survey of The Leader’s critical stance on natural theology, Spencer’s attitude towards religion and his rationale for religious freedom are linked to his Nonconformist background.


Keywords: Herbert Spencer, the Unknowable, New Reformation, science and religion, natural theology, Nonconformity

  1. - Anon. 1850a: Prospectus, The Leader, I (1850), 1, p. 22.
  2. - Anon. 1850b: Newman on the Soul, ivi, I (1850), 2, pp. 38-40.
  3. - Anon. 1850c: The New Reformation, ivi, I (1850), 5, pp. 105-106 - Anon. 1850d: Newman’s Phases of Faith, ivi, I (1850), pp. 206-207, 232-233, 256-258, 281-282, 329-330.
  4. - Anon. 1850e: Mackay’s Progress of the Intellect, ivi, I (1850), 20, pp. 471-473.
  5. - Anon. 1851a: Letters on Man’s Development and Nature, ivi, II (1851), 49, pp. 201-
  6. 203.
  7. - Anon. 1851b: Martineau’s Letters on Man, ivi, II (1851), 50, pp. 227-228.
  8. - Anon. 1851c: Spencer’s Social Statics, ivi, II (1851), pp. 248-250, 274-275, 347-348.
  9. - Anon. 1851d: Lyell and Owen on Development, ivi, II (1851), 82, pp. 996-997.
  10. - Anon. 1852: Theology in Nature, ivi, III (1852), 116, pp. 565-566.
  11. - Anon. 1853a: The Development Hypothesis of the “Vestiges”, ivi, III (1853), pp. 784-785, 812-813.
  12. - Anon. 1853b: Lamarck and the Vestiges, ivi, III (1853), 179, pp. 832-834.
  13. - Anon. 1853c: The Religion of the Heart, ivi, IV (1853), 187, pp. 1024-1026.
  14. - Anon. 1860: Scientific Philosophy, “The Saturday Analyst and Leader”, XI (1860), 553, pp. 896-897.
  15. - Ashton 1991: Rosemary Ashton, G. H. Lewes: A Life, Clarendon Press, Oxford 1991.
  16. - Ashton 2006: Ead., 142 Strand: A Radical Address in Victorian London, Chatto & Windus, London 2006.
  17. - Atkinson, Martineau 1851: Henry G. Atkinson, Harriet Martineau, Letters on the Laws of Man’s Development and Nature, Chapman, London 1851.
  18. - Brooke 1989: John H. Brooke, Scientific Thought and Its Meaning for Religion: The Impact of French Science on British Natural Theology, “Revue de synthèse”, CX (1989), 1, pp. 33-59.
  19. - Corsi 1988: Pietro Corsi, Science and Religion: Baden Powell and the Anglican Debate (1800-1860), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1988.
  20. - Eliot 1851: [George Eliot], Mackay’s Progress of the Intellect, “Westminster Review”, LIV (1851), 2, pp. 353-368.
  21. - Francis 2007: Mark Francis, Herbert Spencer and the Invention of Modern Life, Acumen, Stocksfield 2007.
  22. - L. Hunt 1853: Leigh Hunt, The Religion of the Heart: A Manual on Faith and Duty, Chapman, London 1853.
  23. - T. Hunt 1850: Thornton Hunt, Social Reform, The Leader, I (1850), pp. 445-446, 493-494, 517-518.
  24. - Hutton 1856: [Richard H. Hutton], “Atheism”, National Review, II (1856), 2, pp. 97-123.
  25. - Lanaro 1990: Giorgio Lanaro, Il positivismo tra scienza e religione. Studi sulla fortuna di Comte in Gran Bretagna, Angeli, Milano 1990.
  26. - Lanaro 1997: Id., L’evoluzione, il progresso e la società industriale. Un profilo di Herbert Spencer, La Nuova Italia, Firenze 1997.
  27. - Larsen 1999: Timothy Larsen, Friends of Religious Equality: Nonconformist Politics in Mid-Victorian England, The Bodily Press, Woodbridge 1999.
  28. - Lewes 1850a: [George H. Lewes], The Apprenticeship of Life, The Leader, I (1850), 2, pp. 42-44.
  29. - Lewes 1850b: Id., Social Reform, ivi, The Leader, I (1850), 20, pp. 469-470.
  30. - Lewes 1852: Id., Comte’s Positive Philosophy, ivi, III (1852), pp. 327-328, 353-354, 375-377, 399-402, 420-422, 447-448, 472-473, 496-497, 519-521, 543-545, 567-569, 592-593, 615-617, 665-666, 688-689, 735-736, 761-762, 785-787.
  31. - Lightman 1987: Bernard Lightman, The Origins of Agnosticism: Victorian Unbelief and the Limits of Knowledge, The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore 1987. - Mackay 1850: Robert W. Mackay, The Progress of the Intellect, as exemplified in the Religious Development of the Greeks and Hebrews, 2 vols., Chapman, London 1850.
  32. - Mansel 1858: Henry Mansel, The Limits of Religious Thought examined in Eight Lectures, preached before the University of Oxford, Murray, London 1858.
  33. - Moore 1990: James R. Moore, Theodicy and Society: The Crisis of the Intelligentsia, in Richard J. Helmstadter, Bernard Lightman (eds.), Victorian Faith in Crisis: Essays on Continuity and Change in Nineteenth-Century Religious Belief, Macmillan, Basingstoke 1990, pp. 153-186.
  34. - Newman 1845: [Francis William Newman], Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation, “Prospective Review”, I (1845), pp. 49-82.
  35. - Newman 1852: Id., The Soul, Its Sorrows and Its Aspirations: An Essay towards the Natural History of the Soul, as the True Basis of Theology, 3rd ed., Chapman, London 1852.
  36. - Newman 1860: Id., Phases of Faith: or, Passages from the History of My Creed, 6th ed., Manwaring, London 1860.
  37. - Spencer 1843: Herbert Spencer, The Proper Sphere of Government: A Reprint of a Series of Letters, originally published in “The Nonconformist”, Brittain, London 1843.
  38. - Spencer 1851: Id., Social Statics: or, the Conditions Essential to Human Happiness Specified, and the First of Them Developed, Chapman, London 1851.
  39. - Spencer 1852: [Id.], The Development Hypothesis, The Leader, III (1852), 104, pp. 280-281.
  40. - Spencer 1853: [Id.], The Use of Anthropomorphism, ivi, IV (1853), 189, pp. 1076-1077.
  41. - Spencer 1867: Id., The First Principles, 2nd ed., Williams & Norgate, London 1867.
  42. - Spencer 1873: Id., The Study of Sociology, Williams & Norgate, London 1873.
  43. - Spencer 1904: Id., An Autobiography, 2 vols., Williams & Norgate, London 1904.
  44. - Taylor 1996: Michael W. Taylor, Introduction, in Herbert Spencer, First Principles, Routledge/Thoemmes Press, London 1996, pp. V-XVII.
  45. - Taylor 2007: Id., The Philosophy of Herbert Spencer, Continuum, London 2007.
  46. - Whewell 1833: William Whewell, Astronomy and General Physics considered with reference to Natural Theology, W. Pickering, London 1833.
  47. - Wiltshire 1978: David Wiltshire, The Social and Political Thought of Herbert Spencer, Oxford University Press, Oxford 1978.
  48. - Wright 1986: Terence R. Wright, The Religion of Humanity: The Impact of Comtean Positivism on Victorian Britain, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1986.

Federico Morganti, in "RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA" 1/2016, pp. 47-68, DOI:10.3280/SF2016-001003

   

FrancoAngeli è membro della Publishers International Linking Association associazione indipendente e no profit per facilitare l'accesso degli studiosi ai contenuti digitali nelle pubblicazioni professionali e scientifiche