Clicca qui per scaricare

Teorie della coesione nell’epistolario Leibniz-Hartsoeker
Titolo Rivista: RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA 
Autori/Curatori: Gianfranco Mormino 
Anno di pubblicazione:  2016 Fascicolo: suppl. 4 Lingua: Italiano 
Numero pagine:  16 P. 215-230 Dimensione file:  123 KB
DOI:  10.3280/SF2016-004-S1015
Il DOI è il codice a barre della proprietà intellettuale: per saperne di più:  clicca qui   qui 




Celebrated in his time for a few ponderous works on physics but now practically forgotten, the Dutch scientist Nicolaas Hartsoeker was one of the correspondents with whom Leibniz discussed atomistic philosophy. This essay analyzes the main aspects of their exchange of letters, focusing in particular on the problem of ‘hardness’. While Hartsoeker favors a voluntaristic account, attributing the qualities of matter directly to God’s will, Leibniz looks for an explanation in terms of matter and motion in accordance with mechanical philosophy. The solution Leibniz proposes resorts to the notion of motus conspirans (influenced in part by Hobbes), that is to common motion, which is internal to all solid bodies. He compares this mechanism to "fleuves ou jets" flowing inside the body and endowing it with a consistency which explains cohesion and hardness. The final part of the essay mentions a few problems with this theory, which after Leibniz was universally rejected, in particular by Newton.
Keywords: Leibniz, Hartsoeker, Hobbes, atomism, cohesion, hardness, theory of matter, conspiring motion

  1. - Abbri 1978: Ferdinando Abbri, La chimica del ‘700, Loescher, Torino 1978.
  2. - Abou-Nemeh 2011: Catherine Abou-Nemeh, Leibniz and Hartsoeker’s Letters: what animates Matter in Motion?, in Juan A. Nicolas (ed.), Leibniz y las ciencias empíricas, Comares, Granada 2011, pp. 221-235.
  3. - Aiton 1991: Eric J. Aiton, Leibniz. A Biography, Adam Hilger, Bristol 1985. Trad. it. di Giulietta Pacini Mugnai: Leibniz, a cura di Massimo Mugnai, Il Saggiatore, Milano 1991.
  4. - AK: Gottfried W. Leibniz, Sämtliche Schriften und Briefe, hrsg. von der Preussischen (– Deutschen) Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Berlin, 1923-…
  5. - Berkvens-Stevelinck 1975: Christiane Berkvens-Stevelinck, Nicolas Hartsoeker contre Isaac Newton ou Pourquoi les planètes se meuvent-elles?, in ≪Lias≫, II (1975), pp. 313-328.
  6. - Cittert-Eymers 1970-1980: Johanna G. van Cittert-Eymers, Hartsoeker (or Hartsoecker), Nicolaas, in Charles C. Gillispie (ed.), Dictionary of Scientific Biography, Scribner, New York 1970-1980, V, pp. 148-149.
  7. - De Buzon 2005: Frederic de Buzon, Repos ou mouvement conspirant: Leibniz et les articles 54 et 55 de la partie II des Principia philosophiae, in ≪Revue d’histoire des sciences≫, LVIII (2005), pp. 105-122.
  8. - Descartes 1974-1986: Oeuvres de Descartes, publiees par Charles Adam & Paul Tannery, nouvelle presentation en co-edition avec le Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Vrin, Paris 1974-1986, 13 voll.
  9. - Duchesneau 1993: Francois Duchesneau, Leibniz et la méthode de la science, Presses Universitaires de France, Paris 1993.
  10. - Fontenelle 1825: Éloge de Hartsoeker, in Oeuvres de Fontenelle, précédées d’une notice sur sa vie et ses ouvrages, Salmon, Paris 1825, II, pp. 140-160.
  11. - Gemelli 1997: Benedino Gemelli, Leibniz e l’atomismo classico: dal meccanicismo al biologismo, in ≪Nouvelles de la Republique des Lettres≫, XVII (1997), pp. 49-76.
  12. - Gori 1972: Giambattista Gori, La fondazione dell’esperienza in ‘sGravesande, La Nuova Italia, Firenze 1972.
  13. - GM: Leibnizens mathematische Schriften, hrsg. von Carl I. Gerhardt, Berlin-Halle 1849-1863. Rist. Georg Olms Verlag, Hildesheim-New York 1971, 7 voll.
  14. - GP: Die philosophischen Schriften von Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, hrsg. von Carl I. Gerhardt, Weidmann, Berlin 1875-1890. Rist. Georg Olms Verlag, Hildesheim 1960-1961, 7 voll.
  15. - Grosholz 1994: Emily R. Grosholz, Leibniz’s Correspondence with Hartsoeker and Remond, in Aa. Vv., Leibniz und Europa. Vorträge. VI. Internationaler Leibniz-Kongreß, Gottfried-Wilhelm-Leibniz Gesellschaft, Hannover 1994, pp. 293-300.
  16. - Hartsoeker 1694: Nicolaas Hartsoeker, Essay de dioptrique, Anisson, Paris 1694.
  17. - Hartsoeker 1696: Id., Principes de physique, Anisson, Paris 1696.
  18. - Hartsoeker 1699: Id., Proeve der deurzicht-kunde, in het Frans beschreven van de Heer Nicolaas Hartsoeker; en Vertald door A: Block, By Jan ten Hoorn [...], t’Amsteldam 1699.
  19. - Hartsoeker 1700: Id., Beginsselen der natuur-kunde, In het Frans beschreven van de Heer Nicolaas Hartsoeker; en Vertald door A: Block, By Jan ten Hoorn [...], t’Amsteldam 1700.
  20. - Hartsoeker 1706: Id., Conjectures physiques, Desbordes, Amsterdam 1706.
  21. - Hartsoeker 1710: Id., Eclaircissemens sur les conjectures physiques, Humbert, Amsterdam 1710. - Hartsoeker 1722: Id., Remarques sur deux passages d’une These que Mr. Bernoulli a fait soûtenir à Bâle par un certain Nebel son ecolier, in Recueil de plusieurs pieces de physique, où l’on fait principalement voir l’invalidité du système de M. Newton. Et où se trouve, entre autres, une Dissertation sur la peste & sur les moyens de s’en garentir, Broedelet, Utrecht 1722, pp. 268-288.
  22. - Huygens 1888-1950: Oeuvres complètes de Christiaan Huygens, publiees par la Societe Hollandaise des Sciences, Nijhoff, La Haye 1888-1950, 22 voll. (23 tomi).
  23. - Koyre 1972: Alexandre Koyre, Newtonian studies, Harvard University Press, Cambridge (Mass.) 1965. Trad. it. di Paolo Galluzzi: Studi newtoniani, Einaudi, Torino 1972.
  24. - Lasswitz 1963: Kurd Lasswitz, Geschichte der Atomistik vom Mittelalter bis Newton, Leopold Voss, Hamburg-Leipzig 1890. Rist. Georg Olms Verlag, Hildesheim 1963, 2 voll.
  25. - Malebranche 1974: Nicolas Malebranche, Recherche de la vérité, ed. Genevieve Rodis-Lewis, in Oeuvres complètes, Vrin, Paris 1974, voll.1-3.
  26. - Metzger 1923: Helene Metzger, Les doctrines chimiques en France du début de XVIIe à la fin du XVIIIe siècle, Les Presses Universitaires de France, Paris 1923.
  27. - Millington 1945: E. C. Millington, Theories of Cohesion in the Seventeenth Century, in ≪Annals of science≫, V (1945), pp. 253-269.
  28. - Mormino 1993: Gianfranco Mormino, Penetralia Motus. La fondazione relativistica della meccanica in Christiaan Huygens, con l’edizione del Codex Hugeniorum 7A, La Nuova Italia, Firenze 1993.
  29. - Mormino 2012a: Id., Atomismo e meccanicismo nel pensiero di Huygens, in Spazio, corpo e moto nella filosofia naturale del Seicento, Mimesis, Milano-Udine 2012, pp. 63-96.
  30. - Mormino 2012b: Id., Atomismo e volontà divina nei primi scritti di Leibniz, in Spazio, corpo e moto nella filosofia naturale del Seicento, Mimesis, Milano-Udine 2012, pp. 111-141.
  31. - Mortreux 1924: E. Mortreux, Nicolaas Hartsoeker, in Aa. Vv., Nieuw nederlandsch biografisch woordenboek, Sijthoff, Leiden 1924, VI, coll. 717-720.
  32. - NBG 1858: Anonimo [L. L-T.], Hartsoeker (Nicolas), in Nouvelle biographie générale depuis les temps les plus reculés jusqu’à nos jours, avec les renseignements bibliographiques et l’indications des sources à consulter, sous la direction de M. le Dr. Hoefer, Didot, Paris 1858, XXIII, coll. 477-484.
  33. - Newton 1706: Isaac Newton, Optice: sive de Reflexionibus, Refractionibus, Inflexionibus & Coloribus Lucis libri tres [...]. Latine reddidit Samuel Clarke [...], Smith & Walford, London 1706.
  34. - Newton 1730: Isaac Newton, Opticks: or, a Treatise of the Reflections, Refractions, Inflections and Colours of Light, Innys, London 1730.
  35. - Poggendorff 1863: Johann C. Poggendorff, Hartsoeker, Nicolaus, in Biographisch-literarisches Handwörterbuch zur Geschichte der exacten Wissenschaften [...], Barth, Leipzig 1863, I, coll. 1026-1027.
  36. - Principe 2008: Lawrence M. Principe, Transmuting Chymistry into Chemistry: Eighteenth-Century Chrisopoeia and its Repudiation, in Jose R. Bertomeu-Sanchez – Duncan Thorburn Burns – Brigitte van Tiggelen (eds.), Neighbours and territories. The evolving identity of chemistry, Memosciences, Louvain-la-neuve 2008, pp. 21-34.
  37. - Salvago 1995: Stefano U. Salvago, La teoria della materia di Nicolaas Hartsoeker, in ≪Rivista di storia della scienza≫, III (1995-2), pp. 77-106.
  38. - Sebastiani 1984: Fabio Sebastiani, La fisica dei fenomeni termici nella prima metà del Settecento: le teorie sulla natura del calore da Hartsoeker a Lomonosov, in ≪Physis ≫, XXVI (1984), pp. 29-127. - Scott 1970: Wilson L. Scott, The Conflict between Atomism and Conservation Theory 1644-1860, Mac Donald, London-Elsevier, New York 1970.
  39. - Snelders 1980: Henricus A. M. Snelders, Christiaan Huygens and the Concept of Matter, in Hendrik J. M. Bos et alii (eds.), Studies on Christiaan Huygens. Invited papers from the Symposium on the life and work of Christiaan Huygens, Amsterdam, 22-25 August 1979, Swets & Zeitlinger, Lisse 1980, pp. 104-125.
  40. - Stroup 1993: Alice Stroup, Science, politique et conscience aux débuts de l’Académie Royale des Sciences, in ≪Revue de synthese≫, CXIV (1993), pp. 423-453.
  41. - Thijssen-Schoute 1989: Caroline L. Thijssen-Schoute, Nederlands cartesianisme, Noord-Hollandsche Uitgevers Maatschappij, Amsterdam 1954. Rist. Hes Uitgevers, Utrecht 1989.
  42. - Wilson 1982: Catherine Wilson, Leibniz and Atomism, in ≪Studies in History and Philosophy of Science≫, XIII (1982), pp. 175-199.
  43. - Zuidervaart 2010: Huib J. Zuidervaart, Science for the Public: the Translation of Popular Texts on Experimental Philosophy into the Dutch Language in Mid-Eighteenth Century, in Stefanie Stockhorst (ed.), Cultural Transfer through Translation. The Circulation of Enlightened thought in Europe by Means of Translation / Transferts culturels par voie de traduction: la diffusion de la pensée des Lumières en Europe par la traduction, Rodopi, Amsterdam-New York 2010, pp. 231-262.

Gianfranco Mormino, in "RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA" suppl. 4/2016, pp. 215-230, DOI:10.3280/SF2016-004-S1015

   

FrancoAngeli è membro della Publishers International Linking Association associazione indipendente e no profit per facilitare l'accesso degli studiosi ai contenuti digitali nelle pubblicazioni professionali e scientifiche