Clicca qui per scaricare

Being Alive in Descartes’ Physiology: Animals and Plants, the Immutatio and the Impetus
Titolo Rivista: RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA 
Autori/Curatori: Fabrizio Baldassarri 
Anno di pubblicazione:  2021 Fascicolo: 1  Lingua: Inglese 
Numero pagine:  19 P. 76-94 Dimensione file:  223 KB
DOI:  10.3280/SF2021-001004
Il DOI è il codice a barre della proprietà intellettuale: per saperne di più:  clicca qui   qui 


In René Descartes’ works there are four major references to living bodies as objects of his natural philosophy. The first is contained in the Fifth part of the Discours de la Méthode, published in June 1637, where Descartes provides a mechanical explanation of the heartbeat and other living functions of the body. The second is in a bio-medical note collected in the Excerpta anatomica dated November 1637, where he discusses nutrition and growth. The third is the famous claim on the absence of a section on living bodies in the Principia philosophiae, published in 1644. The fourth is in La Description du corps humain, Descartes’ late physiology likely dated 1647-1648. In this article, by exploring these passages and contextualizing his physiological observations of animals and plants, I reassemble Descartes’ science of life: his dismissal of soul, his mechanical framework, his interpretation of bodily self-maintenance and growth, his understanding of living bodies as integrated and organic systems, and the role of a power such as the immutatio and forces such as the impetus.


Keywords: Descartes, life science, animals, plants, automata, natural philosophy

  1. - Sanhueza 1997 : Gabriel Sanhueza, La pensée biologique de Descartes dans ses rapports avec la philosophie scolastique. Le cas Gomez-Péreira, L’Harmattan, Paris 1997.
  2. - Scribano 2020: Emanuela Scribano, Dio e natura. Da Descartes a Leibniz, in G. Paganini (a cura di)., La filosofia dei moderni, Carocci, Roma 2020, pp. 89-112.
  3. - Shapiro 2003: Lisa Shapiro, The Health of the Body-Machine? Or Seventeenth Century Mechanism and the Concept of Health, «Perspectives on Science», 11/4 (2003), pp. 421-441.
  4. - Toletus 1985: Franciscus Toletus, Opera Omnia philosophica, Hildesheim 1985.
  5. - Verbeek 1993: Theo Verbeek (éd.), Descartes et Regius: Autour de l’explication de l’esprit humain, Rodopi, Amsterdam 1993.
  6. - Verbeek 2014: Theo Verbeek, Fromondus: The Exchange with Descartes Concerning the Discours de la Méthode and the ‘Essays’, «Lias», 41/1 (2014), pp. 69-83.
  7. - Voss 2000: Stephen Voss, Descartes: Heart and Soul, in J.P. Wright and P. Potter (eds.), Psyche and Soma. Physicians and metaphysicians on the mind-body problem from Antiquity to Enlightenment, Clarendon Press, Oxford 2000, pp. 173-196.
  8. - Boulad-Ayoub, Moreau, Torero-Ibad 2011: Josiane Boulad-Ayoub, Pierre-François Moreau, Alexandra Torero-Ibad (éds.), « Matérialisme et cartésianisme », Corpus 61, 2011.
  9. - Ablondi 1998: Fred Ablondi, Automata, Living and Non-Living: Descartes’ Mechanical Biology and His Criteria for Life, «Biology and Philosophy», 13 (1998), pp. 179-186.
  10. - Agostini 2021: Igor Agostini, Vegetative and Sensitive Functions of the Soul in Descartes’ Meditations, in Fabrizio Baldassarri, Andeas Blank (eds.), Vegetative Powers: The Roots of Life in Ancient, Medieval and Early Modern Natural Philosophy, Springer, Cham 2021 (forthcoming).
  11. - Alban-Zapata 2016: Gabriel Alban-Zapata, Light and Man: An Anomaly in the Treatise on Light?, in Delphine Antoine-Mahut and Stephen Gaukroger (eds.), Descartes’ Treatise on Man and its Reception, Springer, Cham 2016, pp. 155-174.
  12. - Alexandrescu 2013: Vlad Alexandrescu, Regius and Gassendi on the Human Soul, «Intellectual History Review», 23 (2013), pp. 433-452.
  13. - Andrault 2016 : Raphaële Andrault, La raison des corps. Mécanisme et sciences médicales, Vrin, Paris 2016.
  14. - Antoine-Mahut 2016: Delphine Antoine-Mahut, The Story of L’Homme, in Delphine Antoine-Mahut and Stephen Gaukroger (eds.), Descartes’ Treatise on Man and its Reception, Springer, Cham 2016, pp. 1-29.
  15. - Aquinas: Thomas Aquinas, In octo libri Physicorum Aristotelis expositio, a cura di Mariano Maggiolo, Torino 1965.
  16. - Aquinas: Thomas Aquinas, S. Thomae Opera omnia, a cura di Roberto Busa, Stuttgart 1980.
  17. - Aristotle De Anima: Aristotle, De Anima, translated and edited by Christopher Shields. Clarendon Press, Oxford 1980.
  18. - Armogathe, Carraud 2003: Jean-Robert Armogathe, Vincent Carraud, Bibliographie cartésienne (1960-1996), Conte Editore, Lecce 2003.
  19. - Arriaga 1632: Roderigo de Arriaga, Cursus philosophicus, Antwerp 1632.
  20. - Aucante 2006: Vincent Aucante, La philosophie médicale de Descartes, Vrin, Paris 2006.
  21. - Baldassarri 2019: Fabrizio Baldassarri, The Mechanical Life of Plants: Descartes on Botany, «British Journal for the History of Science», 52 (2019), pp. 41-63.
  22. - Baldassarri 2021: Fabrizio Baldassarri, Il metodo al tavolo anatomico. Descartes e la medicina, Aracne, Roma 2021.
  23. - Bauhin 1605: Caspard Bauhin, Theatrum anatomicum, Frankfurt 1605.
  24. - Belgioioso: Giulia Belgioioso (a cura di), Bibliografia cartesiana (1997-2012), -- online: http://www.cartesius.net/bibliografia-cartesiana/presentazione (last access 14/1/2021).
  25. - Bellis 2013: Delphine Bellis, Empiricism Without Metaphysics: Regius’ Cartesian Natural Philosophy, in Mihnea Dobre and Tammy Nyden (eds.), Cartesian Empiricism¸ Springer, Dordrecht 2013, pp. 151-184.
  26. - Bertoloni Meli 2019: Domenico Bertoloni Meli, Mechanism: A Visual, Lexical, and Conceptual History, University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh 2019.
  27. - Bitbol-Hespériès 1990: Annie Bitbol-Hespériès, Le principe de vie chez Descartes, Vrin, Paris 1990.
  28. - Bonicalzi 1987: Francesca Bonicalzi, Il costruttore di automi. Descartes e le ragioni dell’anima, Jaca Book, Milano 1987.
  29. - Bos 2002: Erik-Jan Bos, The Correspondence between Descartes and Henricus Regius, PhD diss., Zeno, Utrecht 2002.
  30. - Bos 2013: Erik-Jan Bos, Henricus Regius et les limites de la philosophie cartésienne”, in Delphine Kolesnik-Antoine (éd.), Qu’est-ce qu’être cartésien?, ENS Edition, Lyon 2013, pp. 53-68.
  31. - Bos 2017: Erik-Jan Bos, Descartes and Regius on the Pineal Gland and Animal Spirits, and a Letter of Regius on the True Seat of the Soul, in Stephen Gaukroger and Catherine Wilson (eds.), Descartes and Cartesianism: Essay in Honour of Desmond Clarke, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2017, pp. 95-111.
  32. - Bos 2013: A.P. Bos, The Soul and its Instrumental Body: A Reinterpretation of Aristotle’s Philosophy of Living Nature, Brill, Leiden-Boston 2013.
  33. - Broadie 2001: Sarah Broadie, Soul and Body in Plato and Descartes, «Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society», 101 (2001), pp. 295-308.
  34. - Brown 2011: Deborah Brown, Cartesian Functional Analysis, «Australasian Journal of Philosophy», 90 (2011), pp. 75-92.
  35. - Brown, Normore 2020: Deborah Brown, Calvin Normore, Descartes and the Ontology of Everyday Life, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2020.
  36. - Byers 2006: Sarah Byers, Life as ‘self-motion’: Descartes and ‘the Aristotelians’ on the soul as the life of the body, «The Review of Metaphysics», 59 (2006), pp. 723-755.
  37. - Carraud 1986: Vincent Carraud, L’automate chez Descartes, Pascal et Leibniz, «Publications du Centre International d’Étude de l’Évolution des Idées, des Science et Techniques», CIEEIST, Paris 1986, 82-83, pp. 37-56.
  38. - Cellamare, Bakker 2015: Davide Cellamare and Paul J.J.M. Bakker, Libertus Fromondus’ Christian Psychology. Medicine and Natural Philosophy in the Philosophia christiana De Anima (1649), «Lias», 42, (2015), pp. 37-66.
  39. - Clarke 2010: Desmond Clarke, The Physics and Metaphysics of the Mind: Descartes and Regius, in John Cottingham and Peter Hackerm (eds.), Mind, Method and Morality: Essays in Honour of Anthony Kenny, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2010, pp. 187-207.
  40. - Cohen 1956: Gustave Cohen, Écrivains français en Hollande, Slatkine, Genève 1956.
  41. - Daston, Part 1998: Lorraine Daston and Katherine Park (eds.), Wonders and the Order of Nature, Zone, New York 1998.
  42. - de Buzon 1987: Frédéric de Buzon, Descartes et le matérialisme, «Les Etudes philosophiques», 1987, pp. 11-17. 
  43. - Descartes 1664: René Descartes, L’Homme … avec les Remarques de Louis de La Forge … Paris 1664.
  44. - Descartes 1964-1974 : René Descartes, Œuvres complètes, éd. par Charles Adam and Paul Tannery. 11 vols, Vrin, Paris 1964-1974 [AT].
  45. - Descartes 1984-1991: René Descartes, The Philosophical Writings of Descartes, ed. by John Cottingham, Robert Stoothoff, and Dugald Murdoch, 2 vols, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1984-1991 [CSM].
  46. - Des Chene 1996: Dennis Des Chene, Physiologia: Natural Philosophy in Late Aristotelian and Cartesian Thought, Cornell University Press, Ithaca 1996.
  47. - Des Chene 2000: Dennis Des Chene, Life’s Form: Late Aristotelian Conceptions of the Soul, Cornell University Press, Ithaca 2000.
  48. - Des Chene 2001: Dennis Des Chene, Spirits & Clocks: Machine and Organism in Descartes, Cornell University Press, Ithaca 2001.
  49. - Detlefsen 2016: Karen Detlefsen, Descartes on the Theory of Life and Methodology in the Life Sciences, in Peter Distelzweig, Benjamin Goldberg and Evan Ragland (eds.), Early Modern Medicine and Natural Philosophy, Springer, Boston 2016, pp. 141-171.
  50. - Duchesneau 1998: François Duchesneau, Les modèles du vivant de Descartes à Leibniz, Vrin, Paris 1998.
  51. - Foucher de Careil 1859-1860: Louis-Alexandre Foucher de Careil (éd.), Œuvres inédites de Descartes, Durand, Paris 1859-1860.
  52. - Fowler 1999: C.F. Fowler, Descartes on the Human Soul. Philosophy and the Demands of Christian Doctrine, Kuwler, Dordrecht 1999.
  53. - Fuchs 2001: Thomas Fuchs, The Mechanization of the Heart: Harvey and Descartes, transl. by M. Grene, The University of Rochester Press, Rochester 2001.
  54. - Gaukroger 2000: Stephen Gaukroger, The Resources of a Mechanist Physiology and the Problem of Goal-Directed Processes, in Stephen Gaukroger, John Schuster and John Sutton (eds.), Descartes’ Natural Philosophy, Routledge, London-New York 2000, pp. 383-400.
  55. - Gaukroger 2002: Stephen Gaukroger, Descartes’ System of Natural Philosophy, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2002.
  56. - Gaukroger 2010: Stephen Gaukroger, Descartes’ Theory of Perceptual Cognition and the Question of Moral Sensibility, in John Cottingham and Peter Hackerm (eds.), Mind, Method and Morality: Essays in Honour of Anthony Kenny, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2010, pp. 230-251.
  57. - Giglioni 2018: Guido Giglioni, Touch Me Not: Sense and Sensibility in Early Modern Botany, «Early Science and Medicine», 23/5-6 (2018), pp. 420-443.
  58. - Hall 1970: Thomas S. Hall, Descartes’ Physiological Method: Position, Principles, Examples, «Journal of the History of Biology», 3 (1970), pp. 53-79.
  59. - Hattab 2019: Helen Hattab, Descartes’ Mechanical but not Mechanistic Physics, in Steven Nadler et alii (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Descartes and Cartesianism, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2019, pp. 124-137.
  60. - Heßbrüggen-Walter unpublished: Stefan Heßbrüggen-Walter, Growing Substance: ‘Intussumption’ in the Late Sixteenth Century, unpublished.
  61. - Hutchins 2015: Barnaby R. Hutchins, Descartes, Corpuscles and Reductionims: Mechanism and System in Descartes’ Physiology, «The Philosophical Quarterly», 65 (2015), pp. 669-689.
  62. - Hutchins 2016a: Barnaby R. Hutchins, Descartes and the Dissolution of Life, «The Southern Journal of Philosophy», 54/2 (2016), pp. 155-173.
  63. - Hutchins 2016b: Barnaby R. Hutchins, Does Descartes Have a Principle of Life? Hierarchy and Interdependence in Descartes’s Physiology, «Perspectives on Science», 24/6 (2016), pp. 743-769.
  64. - Kjeller Johansen 2012: Thomas Kjeller Johansen, The Powers of Aristotle’s Soul, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2012.
  65. - Manning 2012: Gideon Manning, Three Biased Reminders about Hylomorphism in Early Modern Science and Philosophy, in Gideon Manning (ed.) Matter and Form in Early Modern Science and Philosophy, Brill, Leiden-Boston 2012, pp. 1-32.
  66. - Manning 2013: Gideon Manning, Descartes’ Healthy Machines and the Human Exception, in Daniel Garber and Sophie Roux (eds.), The Mechanization of Natural Philosophy, Springer, Boston 2013, pp. 237-262.
  67. - Manning 2015: Gideon Manning, Descartes’s Metaphysical Biology, «Hopos», 5 (2015), pp. 209-239.
  68. - Mersenne 1932-1988: Marin Mersenne, Correspondance du P. Marin Mersenne, éd. par Corneliis de Waard et alii, 17 voll., CNRS, Paris 1932-1988.
  69. - Meschini 2018: Franco A. Meschini, Esitazioni cartesiane: embriologia e anti-finalismo, «Physis», 53 (2018), pp. 59-76.
  70. - Mori 2010: Gianluca Mori, Ateismo e materialismo: da Cartesio ai cartesiani radicali, «Alvearium», 3 (2010), pp. 39-48.
  71. - Plempius 1654: Vopiscus Fortunatus, Fundamenta medicinae ad scholae acribologia aptata, Lovanii 1654.
  72. - Riskin 2016: Jessica Riskin, The Restless Clock: A History of the Centuries-Long Argument over What Makes Living Things Tick. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago and London 2016.
  73. - Robinet 1999: André Robinet, Les trois modèles cartésiens d’automates, in J.-N. Missa (éd.), Matière pensante : études historiques sur les conceptions matérialists en philosophie de l’esprit, Vrin, Paris 1999, pp. 35-41.
  74. - Van Ruler 1995: Han Van Ruler, The Crisis of Causality: Voetius and Descartes on God, Nature and Change, Brill, Dordrecht 1995.
  75. - Salgueiro 2012: Ines Salgueiro, Certainty and Forms of Life, in J.P. Galvez, M. Gaffal (eds.), Doubtful Certainties: Language-Games, Forms of Life, Relativism, Verlag, Heusenstamm 2012, pp. 41-52. 

Fabrizio Baldassarri, in "RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA" 1/2021, pp. 76-94, DOI:10.3280/SF2021-001004

   

FrancoAngeli è membro della Publishers International Linking Association associazione indipendente e no profit per facilitare l'accesso degli studiosi ai contenuti digitali nelle pubblicazioni professionali e scientifiche