Expected credit losses and managerial discretion. Current practices and future challenges
Journal Title: MANAGEMENT CONTROL
Author/s: Riccardo Macchioni, Alessandra Allini, Martina Prisco
FullText PDF: 312 KB
(DOI is like a bar code for intellectual property: to have more infomation:
This paper examines the loan loss provisioning behaviour during the transition from IAS 39 to IFRS 9 for a sample of 403 banks in 27 countries in European Union. The objective of the study is to investigate whether during the first years of adoption of the new expected credit loss (ECL) impairment model banks are more en-couraged to smooth earnings and manage capital, compared to the previous in-curred loss (ICL) model. Results show that under ECL, banks adopt a more ag-gressive opportunistic behaviour in accordance with the income-smoothing and capital management approach. Management should be aware of this to implement monitoring and control systems, increasing trustworthiness of financial in-formation for investors’ expectations.
- Ahmed A.S., Takeda C., Thomas S. (1999), Bank loan loss provisions: a re-examination of capital management, earnings management and signalling effects, Journal of Accounting and Economics, 28(1), pp. 1-25.
- Allini A., Caldarelli A., Fiondella C., Spanò R., Zampella A. (2018), Il management accounting fra teoria e prassi. Le esigenze emergenti, in Caldarelli A., Marchi L. (eds), Il sistema di controllo interno nelle imprese non grandi. Elementi costitutivi, dimensioni soggettive e tendenze di integrazione, pp. 15-44.
- Anandarajan A., Hasan I., McCarthy C. (2007), Use of loan loss provisions for capital, earnings management and signalling by Australian banks, Accounting & Finance, 47(3), pp. 357-379.
- Azzali S., Fornaciari L., Mazza T. (2014), Earnings management in bank industry, Economia Aziendale Online, 5(2), pp. 99-110.
- Barnoussi El A., Howieson B., van Beest F. (2020), Prudential Application of IFRS 9: (Un)Fair Reporting in COVID-19 Crisis for Banks Worldwide?! Australian Accounting Review, 30(3), pp. 178-192.
- Barth M.E., Landsman W.R. (2010), How did financial reporting contribute to the financial crisis? European Accounting Review, 19(3), pp. 399-423.
- Battista V., Lucianetti L. (2015), La manipolazione dei valori di bilancio: pressione del management e tratti personali nell’attività del controller, Management Control, 1, pp. 101-132.
- Beatty A., Bin K., Petroni K. R. (2002), Earnings management to avoid earnings declines across publicly and privately held banks, Accounting Review, 77(3), pp. 547-570.
- Beatty A., Liao S. (2014), Financial accounting in the banking industry: A review of the empirical literature, Journal of Accounting and Economics, 58(2-3), pp. 339-383.
- Beaver W., E. Engel (1996), Discretionary behavior with respect to allowances for loan losses and the behavior of security prices, Journal of Accounting and Economics, 22, pp. 177-206.
- Bhat V. (1996), Banks and Income Smoothing: An Empirical Analysis, Applied Financial Economics, 6(6), pp. 505-510.
- Bouvatier V., Lepetit L., Strobel F. (2014), Bank income smoothing, ownership concentration and the regulatory environment, Journal of Banking & Finance, 41, pp. 253-270.
- Bushman R.M., Williams C.D. (2012), Accounting discretion, loan loss provisioning, and discipline of banks’ risk-taking, Journal of Accounting and Economics, 54(1), pp. 1-18.
- Caldarelli A., Marchi L. (2018), Il sistema di controllo interno nelle imprese non grandi. elementi costitutivi, dimensioni soggettive e tendenze di integrazione, Milano, FrancoAngeli.
- Chang R.D., Shen W.H., Fang C.J. (2008), Discretionary Loan Loss Provisions and Earnings Management for the Banking Industry, International Business & Economics Research Journal, 7(3), pp. 9-20.
- Chawla G., Forest L.R., Aguais S.D. (2016), Point-in-Time Loss Given Default Rates and Exposures at Default Models for IFRS 9/CECL and Stress Testing, Journal of Risk Management in Financial Institutions, 9, pp. 249-263.
- Chen C., Kim J.B., L. Yao (2017), Earnings smoothing: does it exacerbate or constrain stock price crash risk? Journal of Corporate Finance, 42, pp. 36-54.
- Cohen B.H., Edwards G.A. (2017), The new era of expected credit loss provisioning, BIS Quarterly Review, pp. 39-59.
- Collins J., Shackelford D., Wahlen J. (1995), Bank differences in the coordination of regulatory capital, earnings and taxes, Journal of Accounting Research, 33(2), pp. 263-292.
- Cummings J.R., Durrani K.J. (2016), Effect of the Basel Accord capital requirements on the loan-loss provisioning practices of Australian banks, Journal of Banking and Finance, 67, pp. 23-36.
- Curcio D., Hasan I. (2015), Earnings and capital management and signaling: The use of loan-loss provisions by European banks, The European Journal of Finance, 21(1), pp. 26-50.
- Danisman G.O., Demir E., Ozili P. (2021), Loan loss provisioning of US banks: Economic policy uncertainty and discretionary behavior, International Review of Economics & Finance, 71, pp. 923-935.
- Davidson R., Goodwin-Stewart J., Kent P. (2005), Internal governance structures and earnings management, Accounting and Finance, 45, pp. 241-267.
- Dechow P., Dichev I. (2002), The quality of accruals and earnings: the role of accrual estimation errors, The Accounting Review, 77, pp. 35-59.
- Dong M., Oberson R. (2020), Moving toward the Expected Credit Loss Model under IFRS 9: Capital Transitional Arrangement and Bank Systematic Risk, SSRN Electronic Journal, pp. 1-56.
- Doyle J., Ge W., McVay S. (2007). Accruals quality and internal control over financial reporting, The Accounting Review, 82, pp. 1141-1170.
- Di Martino G., Dicuonzo G., Galeone G., Dell’Atti V. (2020), Le loan loss provisions nel processo di armonizzazione europea della regolamentazione bancaria, RIREA, 2, pp. 233-256.
- European Banking Authority (EBA) (2017), Final Report Guidelines on credit institutions’ credit risk management practices and accounting for expected credit losses.
- European Central Bank (ECB) (2017), Assessment of institutions’ preparedness for the implementation of IFRS 9.
- European Systemic Risk Board (ESRB) (2017), Financial stability implications of IFRS 9.
- Evans J., Sridhar S. (1996), Multiple control systems, accrual accounting, and earnings management, Journal of Accounting Research, 34(1), pp. 45-65.
- Financial Stability Forum (FSF) (2009), Report of the Financial Stability Forum on Addressing Procyclicality in the Financial System.
- Fonseca A.R., Gonzàlez F. (2008), Cross-country determinants of bank income smoothing by managing loan-loss provisions, Journal of Banking and Finance, 32(2), pp. 217-228.
- Furlong F., Knight Z. (2010), Loss provisions and bank charge-offs in the financial crisis: Lesson learned, FRBSF Economic Letter, 16, pp. 1-5.
- García Osma B., Mora A., Porcuna-Enguix L. (2019), Prudential supervisors´ independence and income smoothing in European banks, Journal of Banking & Finance, 102, pp. 156-176.
- Giner B., Mora A. (2019), Bank loan loss accounting and its contracting effects: the new expected loss models, Accounting and Business Research, 49(6), pp. 726-752.
- Gomaa M., Kanagaretnam K., Mestelman S., Shehata M. (2019), Testing the efficacy of replacing the incurred credit loss model with the expected credit loss model, European Accounting Review, 28(2), pp. 309-334.
- Greenwalt M., Sinkey Jr. J. (1988), Bank loan loss provisions and the income smoothing hypothesis: An empirical analysis, 1976-1984, Journal of Financial Services Research, 1, pp. 301-318.
- G20 (2009) Declaration on Strengthening the Financial System, April 2, London.
- Hashim N.A., Li W., O’Hanlon J. (2016), Expected-loss-based accounting for impairment of financial instruments: The FASB and IASB proposals 2009-2016, Accounting in Europe, 13(2), pp. 229-267.
- Hashim N., Li W., O’Hanlon J. (2019), Reflections on the development of the FASB’s and IASB’s expected-loss methods of accounting for credit losses, Accounting and Business Research, 49(6), pp. 682-725.
- Huizinga H., Laeven L. (2012), Bank valuation and accounting discretion during a financial crisis, Journal of Financial Economics, 106(3), pp. 614-634.
- International Accounting Standard Board (IASB) (2008), Reducing complexity in reporting financial instruments.
- International Accounting Standard Board (IASB) (2011), IAS 39: Financial instruments: Recognition and measurement (Blue Book 2011).
- International Accounting Standard Board (IASB) (2014), IFRS 9: Financial instruments.
- Kanagaretnam K., Lobo G.J., Mathieu R. (2004), Earnings management to reduce earnings variability: evidence from bank loan loss provisions, Review of Accounting and Finance, 3, pp. 128-148.
- Kanagaretnam K., Lobo G.J., Yang D.H. (2005), Determinants of Signaling by Banks through Loan Loss Provisions, Journal of Business Research, 58(3), pp. 312-320.
- Kim J-B., Ng J., Wang C. (2020), The Effect of the Shift to the Expected Credit Loss Model on the Timeliness of Loan Loss Recognition, SSRN Electronic Journal, pp. 1-53.
- Krüger S., Rosch D., Scheule H. (2018), The impact of loan loss provisioning on bank capital requirements, Journal of Financial Stability, 36(C), pp. 114-129.
- Leventis S., Dimitropoulos P.E., Anandarajan A. (2011), Loan Loss Provisions, Earnings Management and Capital management under IFRS: The Case of EU Commercial Banks, Journal of Financial Services Research, 40(1-2), pp. 103-22.
- Li Y., Li X., Xiang E., Djajadikerta H.G. (2020), Financial Distress, Internal Control, and Earnings Management: Evidence from China, Journal of Contemporary Accounting & Economics, 16(3), pp. 1-18.
- Liu C., Yuen Y.C., Yao L.J., Chan S.H. (2014), Differences in earnings management between firms using US GAAP and IAS/IFRS, Review of Accounting and Finance, 13(2), pp. 134-155.
- Lobo G.J., Yang D.H. (2001), Bank managers’ heterogeneous decisions on discretionary loan loss provisions, Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting, 16, pp. 223-250.
- Maffei M. (2016), La disclosure sui rischi: con particolare riferimento alle banche, Torino, Giappichelli.
- Marchi L. (2015), Nuove prospettive di ricerca sulle tematiche di Management Control, Management Control, 3, pp. 5-8.
- Marchi L. (2018), Quale metodologia di ricerca sulle tematiche di Management Control? Management Control, 2, pp. 5-10.
- Marra A., Mazzola P., Prencipe A. (2011), Board Monitoring and Earnings Management Pre-and Post-IFRS, The International Journal of Accounting, 46(2) pp. 205-230.
- Mechelli A., Cimini R., Sforza V. (2020), Is IFRS 9 better than IAS 39 for investors’ decisions? Evidence from the european context at the beginning of the transition year, Financial Reporting, 1, pp. 125-148.
- Moyer S. (1990), Capital adequacy ratio regulations and accounting choices in commercial banks, Journal of Accounting & Economics, 13, pp. 123-54.
- Nilsson F., Stockenstrand A. (2015), Financial accounting and management control. The tensions and conflicts between uniformity and uniqueness, Cham, Springer.
- Novotny-Farkas Z. (2016), The interaction of the IFRS 9 expected loss approach with supervisory rules and implications for financial stability, Accounting in Europe, 13(2), pp. 197–227.
- O’Hanlon J. (2013), Did loan-loss provisioning by UK banks become less timely after implementation of IAS 39?, Accounting and Business Research, 43(1), pp. 225-258.
- Otley D. (1999), Performance management: a framework for management control systems research, Management Accounting Research, 10, pp. 363-382.
- Ozili P.K., Outa E. (2019), Bank earnings management using commission and fee income. The role of investor protection and economic fluctuation, Journal of Applied Accounting Research, 20(2), pp. 172-189.
- Restoy F., Zamil R. (2017), Prudential policy considerations under expected loss provisioning: lessons from Asia, Financial Stability Institute (FSI) Insights on policy implementation, 5, pp. 1-29.
- Simons R. (1995), Levers of control: How managers use innovative control systems to drive strategic renewal, Boston, Harvard Business School Press.
- Shrieves R.E., Dahl D. (2003), Discretionary accounting and the behavior of Japanese banks under financial distress, Journal of Banking and Finance, 27, pp. 1219-1243.
- Soedarmono W., Pramono S.E., Tarazi A. (2017), The procyclicality of loan loss provisions in Islamic banks, Research in International Business and Finance, 39, pp. 911-919.
- Tran D.V., Hassan M.K., Houston R. (2020), Discretionary loan loss provision behavior in the US banking industry, Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting, 55, pp. 605-645.
- Van Tendeloo B., Vanstraelen A. (2005), Earnings management under German GAAP versus IFRS, European Accounting Review, 14(1), pp. 155-180.
- Wahlen J. (1994), The Nature of Information in Commercial Bank Loan Loss Disclosures, The Accounting Review, pp. 455-478.
- Wali S., Masmoudi S.M. (2020), Internal control and real earnings management in the French context», Journal of Financial Reporting and Accounting, 18(2), pp. 363-387.
Riccardo Macchioni, Alessandra Allini, Martina Prisco, in "MANAGEMENT CONTROL" 3/2021, pp. 111-134, DOI:10.3280/MACO2021-003006