Causes and implications of the auditor changes

Journal title MANAGEMENT CONTROL
Author/s Silvia Ferramosca, Giulio Greco
Publishing Year 2015 Issue 2015/3
Language Italian Pages 23 P. 93-115 File size 136 KB
DOI 10.3280/MACO2015-003006
DOI is like a bar code for intellectual property: to have more infomation click here

Below, you can see the article first page

If you want to buy this article in PDF format, you can do it, following the instructions to buy download credits

Article preview

FrancoAngeli is member of Publishers International Linking Association, Inc (PILA), a not-for-profit association which run the CrossRef service enabling links to and from online scholarly content.

This paper explores causes and implications of the auditor changes. We investigate the US setting in which the changes are voluntary and there is mandatory disclosure about the reasons for the change. The findings show that changes with a departing Big-4 are motivated by the auditor’s concerns about the client firm weaknesses in internal control processes and compliance with law. The changes between Non-Big-4 auditors are associated with the issuance of going concern qualified opinions, suggesting possible audit opinion shopping by client firms. The switches from a Non-Big-4 to a Big-4 auditor are associated with issues related to the application of accounting standards. Overall, our findings suggest that changes allow auditors to better organise their audit, and balance the objectives of their assignments and the maintenance of effective client relations. The balance of reasonably effective internal controls systems and of risk-proportioned audit fees is at the core of negotiations between audit and client firms. Also, the search for more effective audit and higher governance and financial markets reputation may motivate the switch from a smaller audit firm to a Big-4. The information regarding auditor changes can shed light upon the financial reporting practices and management behaviour, signalling to investors any potential misrepresentation, to the management potential risk areas and to regulators where they might need to intervene to enforce auditor and management independence.

Keywords: Auditor change, Big-4, internal controls, auditor independence

  1. Allegrini M., & D’onza G. (2011), Corporate governance, risk management e responsabilità sociale fra presente e futuro dell’attività di internal auditing, Management Control. DOI: 10.3280/MACO2014-003005
  2. Amodeo D. (1966), La certificazione dei bilanci, Rivista dei Dottori Commercialisti.
  3. Amodeo D. (1979), I principi contabili e la certificazione dei bilancio: contenuti e limiti, Notizie IRI, gennaio-febbraio.
  4. Archambeault D. & Dezoort T.F. (2001), Auditor opinion shopping and the audit committee: An analysis of suspicious auditor switches, International Journal of Auditing, 5, 33-52.
  5. Arel B., Brody R.G. & Pany K. (2005), Audit firm rotation and audit quality, The CPA Journal.
  6. Azzali S., & Mazza T. (2011), La valutazione degli Information Technology Contro nell’ambito dei sistemi di controllo interno: i risultati di una ricerca empirica, Management Control. DOI: 10.3280/MACO2011-003005
  7. Beck P.J. & Wu M.G.H. (2006), Learning by doing and Audit Quality, Contemporary Accounting Research, 23, 1-30. DOI: 10.1506/AXU4-Q7Q9-3YAB-4QE0
  8. Becker C.L., Defond M.L., Jiambalvo J. & Subramanyam K.R. (1998), The Effect of Audit Quality on Earnings Management, Contemporary Accounting Research, 15.
  9. Bruni G. (1976), La revisione aziendale. Principi, metodi, procedure, Milano.
  10. Bruni G. (1996), La revisione aziendale, Quarta edizione, Torino, UTET Libreria.
  11. Bruni G. (2004), La revisione dei conti. Tracce storiche e recenti sviluppi, Rivista dei Dottori Commercialisti, 739-765.
  12. Cameran M., Francis J.R., Marra,A. & Pettinicchio A. (2015), Are There Adverse Consequences of Mandatory Auditor Rotation? Evidence from the Italian Experience, Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory, 34, 1-24.
  13. Cameran M., Gabbioneta C., Moizer P. & Pettinicchio A. (2010), What do Client-firms Think of their Auditors? Evidence from the Italian Market, Corporate Reputation Review, 12, 316-326. DOI: 10.1057/crr.2009.23
  14. Capaldo P. (1980), La certificazione dei bilanci: contenuti e limiti, Rivista dei Dottori Commercialisti, 3.
  15. Carey P.J., Geiger M.A. & O’connell B.T. (2008), Costs Associated With Going-Concern-Modified Audit Opinions: An Analysis of the Australian Audit Market, Abacus, 44, 61-81. DOI: 10.1111/j.1467-6281.2007.00249.x
  16. Cassandro P.E. (1980), Revisione aziendale e certificazione di bilanci: l’esperienza americana ei suoi insegnamenti, Rivista dei Dottori Commercialisti, 31, 1081-1094.
  17. Cassell C.A., Giroux G.A., Myers L.A. & Omer T.C. (2012), The Effect of Corporate Governance on Auditor-Client Realignments, Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory, 31, 167-188.
  18. Chi W. & Huang H. (2005), Discretionary Accruals, Audit-Firm Tenure and Audit-Partner Tenure: Empirical Evidence from Taiwan, Journal of Contemporary Accounting & Economics, 1, 65-92.
  19. Choi S., Choi Y.-S., Gul F.A. & Lee W.-J. (2015), The impact of mandatory versus voluntary auditor switches on stock liquidity: Some Korean evidence, The British Accounting Review, 47, 100-116.
  20. Corbella S., Florio C., Gotti G. & Mastrolia S.A. (2012), Mandatory Auditor Rotation, Audit Fees and Audit Quality. SSRN [Online]. [Accessed 3/05/2015].
  21. Dezzani F., Pisoni P., Puddu L., Cantino V. (1998), La certificazione del bilancio. Il revisore contabile e il collegio sindacale, Giappichelli, Torino.
  22. D'Onza G. (2008), Il sistema di controllo interno nella prospettiva del risk management, Giuffrè editore.
  23. Davidson Iii W.N., Jiraporn P. & Dadalt P.J. (2006), Causes and Consequences of Audit Shopping: An Analysis of Auditor Opinions, Earnings Management, and Auditor Changes, Quarterly Journal of Business and Economics, 45, 69-87.
  24. Davis L.R., Soo B.S. & Trompeter G.M. (2009), Auditor Tenure and the Ability to Meet or Beat Earnings Forecasts, Contemporary Accounting Research, 26, 517-548. DOI: 10.1506/car.26.2.8
  25. DeAngelo L.E. (1981), Auditor size and audit quality, Journal of Accounting & Economics, 3, 183-199. DOI: 10.1016/0165-4101(81)90002-1
  26. DeFond M., Ettredge M. & Smith D.B. (1997), An investigation of auditor resignations, Research in Accounting Regulation, 11, 25-46. DeFond M.L. & Subramanyam K.R. (1998), Auditor changes and discretionary accruals, Journal of Accounting & Economics, 25, 35-67. DOI: 10.1016/S0165-4101(98)00018-4
  27. Dell’Atti A. (1985), Osservazioni in materia di revisione e certificazione di bilanci e di situazioni aziendali, Rivista dei Dottori Commercialisti, 5.
  28. Dezzani F. (1974), La certificazione del bilancio d'esercizio: contenuto, obiettivi e tecniche di revisione, A. Giuffrè.
  29. Di Pietra R. (2005), La revisione contabile in Italia e nella prospettiva internazionale, CEDAM, Padova.
  30. Ding R. & Jia Y. (2012), Auditor mergers, audit quality and audit fees: Evidence from the PricewaterhouseCoopers merger in the UK, Journal of Accounting and Public Policy, 31, 69-85. DOI: 10.1016/j.jaccpubpol.2011.08.002
  31. Francis J.R. & Wilson E.R. (1988), Auditor changes: A joint test of theories relating to agency costs and auditor differentiation, The Accounting Review, LXIII, 663-682.
  32. Hackenbrack K.E. & Hogan C.E. (2002), Market Response to Earnings Surprises Conditional on Reasons for an Auditor Change, Contemporary Accounting Research, 19, 195-223. DOI: 10.1506/5XW7-9CY6-LLJY-BA2F
  33. Hair J.F., Anderson R.E., Tatham R.L. & Black W. (1984), Multivariate data analysis with readings, 1995, NewYork, NY Macmillan.
  34. Hinna L., Messier W.F. (2007), Auditing: fondamenti di revisione contabile, McGraw-Hill libri Italia.
  35. Imhoff E.A. (2003), Accounting Quality, Auditing, and Corporate Governance, Accounting Horizons, 17.
  36. Jennings M.M., Pany K.J. & Reckers P.M.J. (2006), Strong corporate governance and audit firm rotation: Effects on judges’ independence perceptions and litigation judgments, Accounting Horizons, 20, 253-270.
  37. Johnstone K.M. & Bedard J.C. (2004), Audit Firm Portfolio Management Decisions, Journal of Accounting Research, 42, 659-690. DOI: 10.1111/j.1475-679X.2004.00153.x
  38. Kim Y. & Park M.S. (2014), Real Activities Manipulation and Auditors’ Client-Retention Decisions, The Accounting Review, 89, 367-401. DOI: 10.2308/accr-5058
  39. Krishnan G.V. & Visvanathan G. (2007), Reporting Internal Control Deficiencies in the Post-Sarbanes-Oxley Era: The Role of Auditors and Corporate Governance, International Journal of Auditing, 11, 73-90. DOI: 10.1111/j.1099-1123.2007.00358.x
  40. Krishnan J. & Krishnan J. (1997), Litigation Risk and Auditor Resignation, The Accounting Review, 72, 539-560.
  41. Lamboglia, R., D’Onza, G. (2013), Un modello di gestione del rischio reputazionale. Dall’identificazione al fronteggiamento, Management Control, 3, pp. 7-34. DOI: 10.3280/MACO2013-003002
  42. Lee H.Y., Mande V. & Ortman R. (2004), The effect of audit committee and board of director independence on auditor resignation, Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory, 23, 131-146.
  43. Lys T.,Z. & Watts R.L. (1994), Lawsuits against Auditors, Journal of Accounting Research, 32, 65-93.
  44. Mainardi M. (2004), I servizi di “assurance” e le relazioni emesse dalle società di revisione. Audit, review, agreed-upon procedures, compilation, Padova, Cedam.
  45. Marchi L. (2011), L’evoluzione del controllo di gestione nella prospettiva informativa e gestionale esterna, Management Control, 3, pp. 5-16. DOI: 10.3280/MACO2011-003001
  46. Marchi L. (2012), Revisione aziendale e sistemi di controllo interno, Milano, Giuffrè. Menon K. & Williams D.D. (2008), Management Turnover Following Auditor Resignations, Contemporary Accounting Research, 25, 567-604. DOI: 10.1506/car.25.2.10
  47. Romanus R., Maher J.J. & Fleming D.M. (2008), Auditor industry specialization, auditor changes, and accounting restatements, Accounting Horizons, 22, 389-413.
  48. Shu Z.S. (2000), Auditor resignations: Clientele effects and legal liability, Journal of Accounting & Economics, 29, 173-205.
  49. Solomon I., Shields M.D. & Whittington R.O. (1999), What do Industry-Specialist Auditors Know? Journal of Accounting Research, 37, 191-208.
  50. Ubersax J.S. (2006), Introduction to the tetrachoric and polychoric correlation coefficients, Link: http://www. john-uebersax. com/stat/tetra. htm.
  51. Vanstraelen A. (2003), Going concern opinions, auditor switching, and the self-fulfilling prophecy effect examined in the regulatory context of Belgium, Journal of Accounting, Auditing & Finance, 18, 231-253. DOI: 10.1177/0148558X0301800204
  52. Viganò E. & De Cicco R. (1983), La revisione del bilancio di esercizio, Milano.
  53. Wang K.J. & Tuttle B.M. (2009), The impact of auditor rotation on auditor–client negotiation, Accounting, Organizations and Society, 34, 222-243. DOI: 10.1016/j.aos.2008.06.003
  54. Williams D.D. (1988), The potential determinants of auditor change, Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, 15, 243-261.
  55. Wooldridge J.M. (2002), Introductory Econometrics - A Modern Approach. Woo E.-S. & Koh H.C. (2001), Factors associated with auditor changes: A Singapore study, Accounting and Business Research, 31, 133-144.
  56. Zambon S. (1997), Alle origini della revisione contabile, il Mulino.

  • Esiste una strategia di Internal Auditing che crea valore? Un'analisi empirica del contesto italiano Giuseppe D'Onza, Alessandra Rigolini, Francesco Brotini, in MANAGEMENT CONTROL 1/2016 pp.125
    DOI: 10.3280/MACO2016-001008
  • Un framework integrato per la misura dell'innovazione del Piano Nazionale Scuola Digitale (PNSD) Domenico Consoli, Selena Aureli, in MANAGEMENT CONTROL 1/2018 pp.139
    DOI: 10.3280/MACO2018-001007

Silvia Ferramosca, Giulio Greco, Cause e implicazioni del cambiamento del revisore in "MANAGEMENT CONTROL" 3/2015, pp 93-115, DOI: 10.3280/MACO2015-003006