Crossing and permutation: On a recurring schema for explaining error in philosophy in the classical period.
Journal title RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA
Author/s Denis Moreau
Publishing Year 2016 Issue 2016/4
Language French Pages 17 P. 615-631 File size 58 KB
DOI 10.3280/SF2016-004005
DOI is like a bar code for intellectual property: to have more infomation
click here
Below, you can see the article first page
If you want to buy this article in PDF format, you can do it, following the instructions to buy download credits
FrancoAngeli is member of Publishers International Linking Association, Inc (PILA), a not-for-profit association which run the CrossRef service enabling links to and from online scholarly content.
In this article the Author analyzes a recurring schema among early modern thinkers as they reflect on the manner in which error occurs. It can be called the explanation of error by permutation or crossing. First, there is quick formal presentation of what is to be understood by these expressions. Then, several examples are shown of this mode of explanation of error, primarily in Descartes (along with some references to Malebranche and Spinoza). This is followed by a discussion of a thinker in whom this schema is particularly evident in a number of domains - Pascal. The aim is to suggest that this configuration has in his writings not only a descriptive function with respect to error as a fact, but also a heuristic role. The Author ends with some reflections on the signification of the presence, and recurrence, of this schema among early modern philosophers when they address the question of error.
Keywords: Error, Descartes, Pascal, conceptual crossing, conceptual permutation
- - Arnauld 2003: Antoine Arnauld, OEuvres philosophiques, 6 vol., publiées par Elmar Kremer et Denis Moreau, Thoemmes, Bristol 2003. 3. Réflexions philosophiques et théologiques I et II.
- - Bergson 2012: Henri Bergson, Matière et mémoire, PUF, Paris 2012.
- - Bergson 2013: Id., Essai sur les données immédiates de la conscience, PUF, Paris 2013.
- - Bonino 2006: Serge-Thomas Bonino, ‘Toute vérité, quel que soit celui qui la dit, vient de l’Esprit-Saint’: autour d’une citation de l’Ambrosiaster dans le corpus thomasien, «Revue Thomiste», janvier-juin 2006, pp. 101-148.
- - Deleuze 2011: Gilles Deleuze, Le Bergsonisme, PUF, Paris 2011. -Descartes, AT: René Descartes, Oeuvres, ed. par Charles Adam and Paul Tannery, Vrin-CNRS, Paris 1964-1974
- - Grimaldi 1988: Nicolas Grimaldi, Sur l’infinité de la volonté et la ressemblance de l’homme avec Dieu, dans Id., Six études sur la volonté et la liberté chez Descartes, Vrin, Paris 1988, pp. 25-41.
- - Kambouchner 2008: Denis Kambouchner, Descartes et la perfection de la morale, dans Id., Descartes et la philosophie morale, Hermann, Paris 2008, pp. 311-338.
- - Malebranche, OC: Nicolas Malebranche, OEuvres complètes publiées sous la direction d’André Robinet, Vrin, Paris 1958-70.
- -Migne, PG : Migne, Patrologia cursus completus …. Series graeca, accurante J.-P. Migne, apud J.-P. Migne, Lutetia Parisorum
- - Moreau 1999: Denis Moreau, Deux cartésiens. La polémique entre Antoine Arnauld et Nicolas Malebranche, Vrin, Paris 1999.
- - Pascal 1963: Blaise Pascal, OEuvres complètes, édition Louis Lafuma, Seuil, Paris 1963
- - Rimbaud 1960: Arthur Rimbaud, Les Soeurs de charité, dans Id., OEuvres, edition Suzanne Bernard, Classiques Garnier, Paris 1960, pp. 108-109.
- - Sartre 1947: Jean-Paul Sartre, La liberté cartésienne, dans Id., Situations I, Gallimard, Paris 1947, pp. 314-335.
- - Singer 2001: Christiane Singer, Où cours-tu?, Albin Michel, Paris 2001.
- - Spinoza 2010: Spinoza, Éthique, texte latin et traduction par Bernard Pautrat, Seuil, Paris 2010.
- - Verne 2005: Jules Verne, Le Rayon vert, Le Livre de poche, Paris 2005.
Denis Moreau, Croisement, permutation: sur un schéma récurrent d’explication de l’erreur dans les philosophies de l’âge classique in "RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA" 4/2016, pp 615-631, DOI: 10.3280/SF2016-004005