Stateless Money and State Power: Europe as ordoliberal Ordnungsgefüge

Journal title HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT AND POLICY
Author/s Werner Bonefeld
Publishing Year 2018 Issue 2018/1
Language English Pages 22 P. 5-26 File size 250 KB
DOI 10.3280/SPE2018-001001
DOI is like a bar code for intellectual property: to have more infomation click here

Below, you can see the article first page

If you want to buy this article in PDF format, you can do it, following the instructions to buy download credits

Article preview

FrancoAngeli is member of Publishers International Linking Association, Inc (PILA), a not-for-profit association which run the CrossRef service enabling links to and from online scholarly content.

Since the start of the Euro crisis there has been an abundance of literature that identifies an ordoliberal Europe with the politics of austerity. This literature is confronted by the paradox that the Euro is a stateless currency. Ordoliberalism holds that economic orders are politically constituted and sustained. The article contends that the exploration of ordoliberal principles of economic constitution and Ordnungspolitik uncovers the crucial role of the member states in monetary union. What monetary union integrates is the role of the state in establishing and sustaining a framework for the domestic conduct of economic activity. In detail, in monetary union the democratically constituted member states assume the role of federated executive states of European money, which governs the decentralised relations of competitive adjustment in territorialised labour markets. The European economic order depends on the commitment and capacity of the member states to make it work within their jurisdictions.

Keywords: Ordoliberalism, European Integration, Euro, Executive State, Government

Jel codes: B2, E5, H1, P59

  1. Eucken W. (1932). Staatliche Strukturwandlungen und die Krise des Kapitalismus, Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, 36: 297-321.
  2. Agnoli J. (1990). Die Transformation der Demokratie, Freiburg, Ca Ira.
  3. Baimbridge M., B. Burkett and P. Whyman (eds.) (2000). The Impact of the Euro, London, Palgrave. Bernholz P. (1989). Ordo-liberals and the Control of the Money Supply. In Peacock A. and H. Willgerodt (eds.) (1989a): 191-215.
  4. Eucken W. (1952). This Unsuccessful Age, London, Hodge. Eucken W. ([1937] 1959). Die Grundlagen der Nationalökonomie, Berlin, Springer.
  5. Bernholz P. (2013). The Slow and Hidden Road to Serfdom, Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung. Accessed 21 March 2016. -- http://blogs.faz.net/fazit/2013/06/20/the-slow-and-hiddenroadtoserfdom-1933/.
  6. Biebricher T. (2014). The Return of Ordoliberalism in Europe – Notes on a Research Agenda, Rivista quadrimestrale on-line: www. i-lex. it 21: 1-24.
  7. Biebricher T. (2015). Neoliberalism and Democracy, Constellations, 22(2): 255-66. DOI: 10.1111/1467-8675.12157
  8. Bohm F. (1933). Wettbewerb und Monopolkampf, Berlin, Heymann.
  9. Bohm F. (1937). Ordnung der Wirtschaft, Berlin, Kohlhammer.
  10. Bohm F. (1973). Die Kampfansage an Ordnungstheorie und Ordnungspolitik. Zu einem Aufstaz im Kyklos, Ordo, 24: 11-48.
  11. Bohm F. ([1966] 2010). Extracts from Franz Böhm: “Private Law Society and Market Economy”. In Koslowski P. (ed.) (2010): 148-88.
  12. Bonefeld W. (2000). The Spectre of Globalization. In Bonefeld W. and K. Psychopedis (eds.) The Politics of Change: 31–68, London, Palgrave.
  13. Bonefeld W. (2005). Europe, the Market and the Transformation of Democracy, Journal of Contemporary European Studies, 13(1): 93-106. DOI: 10.1080/14782800500061138
  14. Bonefeld W. (2012). Freedom and the strong state: On German ordoliberalism, New Political Economy, 17(5): 633-656. DOI: 10.1080/13563467.2012.656082
  15. Bonefeld W. (2013). Adam Smith and Ordoliberalism: On the political form of market liberty, Review of International Studies, 39 (2): 233-250. DOI: 10.1017/S0260210512000198
  16. Bonefeld W. (2016). Authoritarian Liberalism: From Schmitt via Ordoliberalism to the Euro, Critical Sociology, online first. DOI: 10.1177/0896920516662695
  17. Bonefeld W. (2017). The Strong State and the Free Economy, London, Rowman & Littlefield.
  18. Bonefeld W. (2018). Ordoliberalism and Political Theology. In Hien J. and C. Joerges (eds.) Ordoliberalism, Law and the Rule of Economics: 273-288, Oxford, Hart.
  19. Braunberger G. (2013). Walter Eucken: Der wahre Neoliberale, Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung. Accessed 21 August 2017 -- http://www.faz.net/aktuell/wirtschaft/wirtschaftswissen/die-weltverbesserer/walter-eucken-der-wahre-neoliberale-12625484.html.
  20. Bulmer S. and J. Joseph (2016). European Integration in Crisis?, European Journal of International Relations, 22(4): 725-48. DOI: 10.1177/135406115612558
  21. Burnham P. (1995). Capital, Crisis and the International State System. In Bonefeld W. and J. Holloway (eds.), Global Capital and National State: 92-115. London: Palgrave.
  22. Burnham P. (2014). Depoliticisation: Economic Crisis and Political Management, Policy & Politics, 42 (2): 189-206. DOI: 10.1332/030557312X655954
  23. Currie D. (2000). EMU: Threats and Opportunities for Companies and National Economies. In Baimbridge M., B. Burkett and P. Whyman (eds.) (2000): 113-38.
  24. Curzon G. (1989). International Economic Order: Contribution of Ordo-Liberals. In Peacock A. and H. Willgerodt (eds.) (1989a): 179-90.
  25. Dardot P. and C. Laval (2013). The New Way of the World: On Neoliberal Society, London, Verso.
  26. Eltis W. (2000). British EMU Membership Would Create Instability and Destroy Employment. In Mark Baimbridge M., B. Burkett and P. Whyman (eds.) (2010): 139-59.
  27. Emerson M. (1992). One Market, One Money, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
  28. Engel C. (2003). Imposed Liberty and Its Limits. In Einhorn T. (ed.) Spontaneous Order, Organization and the Law: Roads to a European Civil Society: 429-37 The Hague, Asser Press.
  29. Eucken W. ([1946] 1961). Eucken Gutachten. In Moeller H. (ed.) Zur Vorgeschichte der Deutschen Mark. Die Währungsreformpläne 1945-1948: 202-11, Basel, Kyklos.
  30. Eucken W. ([1948] 1989). What Kind of Economic and Social System?, In Peacock A. and H. Willgerodt (eds.) (1989b): 27-45.
  31. Eucken W. ([1952] 2004). Grundsätze der Wirtschaftspolitik, Tubingen, Mohr Siebert.
  32. Everson M. (1995). Economic Rights within the European Union. In Bellamy R., V. Bufacchi and D. Castiglione (eds.), Democracy and Constitutional Culture in the Union of Europe: 137-52, London, Lothian Foundation Press.
  33. Everson M. and C. Jorges (2013). Who Is the Guardian for Constitutionalism in Europe after the Financial Crisis?, LSE Europe in Question Discussion Paper Series, 63. Accessed 22 August 2017. -- http://www.lse.ac.uk/europeanInstitute/LEQS%20Discussion%20Paper%20Series/LEQSPaper63.pdf.
  34. Feld L. (2012). Europa in der Welt von heute: Wilhelm Ropke und die Zukunft der Europäischen Wahrungsunion, ORDO, 63: 429-48.
  35. Feld L., E. Kohler and D. Nientiedt (2015). Ordoliberalism, Pragmatism and the Eurozone Crisis: How the German Tradition Shaped Economic Policy in Europe, European Review of International Studies, 2(3): 48-61.
  36. Flassbeck H. and C. Lapavitsas (2015). Against the Troika: Crisis and Austerity in the Eurozone, London, Verso.
  37. Friedman M. (1951a). Neo-Liberalism and Its Prospects, Farmand, 17: 89-93.
  38. Friedman M. (1951b). Commodity-Reserve Currency, Journal of Political Economy, 59(3): 203-232. DOI: 10.1086/257077
  39. Gerber D. (1994). Constitutionalising the Economy: German Neo-Liberalism, Competition Law and the “new” Europe, American Journal of Comparative Law, 42(1): 25-74. DOI: 10.2307/840727
  40. Haas E. B. (1958). The Uniting of Europe: Political, Social and Economic Forces, 1950-1957, London, Stevens.
  41. Habermas J. (2012). The Crisis of European Union, Cambridge, Polity.
  42. Hallstein W. (1972). Europe in the Making, London, Georg Allen & Unwin.
  43. Haselbach D. (1991). Autoritarer Liberalismus und Soziale Marktwirtschaft, Baden-Baden, Nomos.
  44. Hayek F. (1944). The Road to Serfdom, London, Routledge.
  45. Hayek F. ([1939] 1949). The Economic Conditions of Interstate Federalism. In Hayek F., Individualism and Economic Order: 255-73, London, Routledge and Kegan Paul.
  46. Heller H. ([1933] 2015). Authoritarian Liberalism, European Law Journal, 21(3): 295-301.
  47. Hix S. (1999). The Political System of the European Union, London, Palgrave.
  48. Issing O. (2000). Walter Eucken: vom Primat der Wahrungspolitik. Vortrag Walter-Eucken-Institut, Freiburg, Accessed 21 August 2017. -- https://www.ecb.europa.eu/press/key/date/2000/html/sp000317_2.de.html.
  49. Jackson B. (2010). At the Origins of Neo-Liberalism: The Free Economy and the Strong State, 1930-1947, The Historical Journal, 53 (1): 129-51. DOI: 10.1017/S0018246X09990392
  50. Jacoby W. (2014). The Politics of the Eurozone Crisis, German Politics and Society, 32 (2): 70-85.
  51. Joerges C. (2005). What Is Left of the European Economic Constitution?, European Law Review, 30(4): 461-89.
  52. Joerges C. and M. Weimer (2014). A Crisis of Executive Managerialism in the EU: No Alternative. In de Burca G., C. Kilpatrick and J. Scott (eds.) Critical Legal Perspectives on Global Governance: 295-322, Oxford, Hart. Köhler E. and D. Nientied (2017). The Muethesius Controversy: A Tale of Two Liberalisms, History of Political Economy, 49(4): 607-630. DOI: 10.1215/00182702-4296329
  53. Koslowski, P. (ed.) (2010). The Theory of Capitalism in the German Economic Tradition, Berlin, Springer.
  54. Lutz F. A. ([1935] 1989). The Functioning of the Gold Standard. In Peacock A. and H. Willgerodt (eds.) (1989b): 209-40.
  55. Lutz F. A. (1949). Geldpolitik und Wirtschaftsordnung, ORDO, 2: 207-28.
  56. Masini F. (2015). European integration: contrasting models and perspectives. In Fiorentini R. and G. Montani (eds.), The European Union and Supranational Political Economy: 44-64, London, Routledge.
  57. Masini F. (2016). Tommaso Padoa-Schioppa: EMU as the Anchor Stone for Building a Federal Europe. In Dyson K. and I. Maes (eds.), Architects of the Euro. Intellectuals in the Making of European Monetary Union: 193-211, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
  58. Masini F. (2017). Trading-Off National and Supranational Collective Goods: The Birth and Death of Neoliberal Pluralism, International Journal of Political Economy, 45(4): 339-356. DOI: 10.1080/08911916.2016.1270085
  59. Mestmäcker E.-J. (2003). Wirtschaft und Verfassung in der Europäischen Union, Baden-Baden, Nomos.
  60. Miksch L. (1947). Wettbewerb als Aufgabe, Bad Godesberg, Kuepper.
  61. Moss B. H. (2000). The European Community as Monetarist Construction, Journal of European Area Studies, 8(2): 247-65. DOI: 10.1080/14608460020014194
  62. Moss B. H. (2001). The EC’s Free Market Agenda and the Myth of Social Europe. In Bonefeld W. (ed.) The Politics of Europe: 107-135, London, Palgrave.
  63. Müller-Armack A. (1932). Entwicklungsgesetze des Kapitalismus, Berlin, Junker & Dünnhaupt.
  64. Müller-Armack A. (1947). Die Wirtschaftsordnungen sozial gesehen, ORDO 1: 125–55.
  65. Müller-Armack A. (1956). Soziale Marktwirtschaft. In von Beckerath E. and C. Brinkman (eds.), Handbuch der Sozialwissenschaften, vol. 9: 390–92, Stuttgart, Fischer.
  66. Müller-Armack A. (1971). Auf dem Weg nach Europa. Erinnerungen und Ausblicke, Tübingen, Wunderlich.
  67. Müller-Armack A. (1978). The Social Market Economy as an Economic and Social Order, Review of Social Economy, 36(3): 325-31. DOI: 10.1080/00346767800000020
  68. Müller-Armack A. (1979). Thirty Years of Social Market Economy. In Thesing J. (ed.) Economy and Development: 146-62, Mainz, Hase und Köhler.
  69. Müller Armack A. (1981). Genealogie der Sozialen Marktwirtschaft, Stuttgart, Paul Haupt.
  70. Nove A. (1983). The Economics of Feasible Socialism, London, Routledge.
  71. O’Rourke, K. H. and A. M. Taylor (2013). Cross of Euros, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 27(3): 167-92.
  72. Padoa-Schioppa, T. (1994). The Road to Monetary Union, Oxford, Clarendon Press.
  73. Radice H. (2015). Global Capitalism, London, Routledge.
  74. Peacock A. and H. Willgerodt (eds.) (1989a). German Neo-Liberals and the Social Market Economy, London, Macmillan.
  75. Peacock A. and H. Willgerodt (eds.) (1989b). Germany’s Social Market Economy: Origins and Evolution, London, Macmillan.
  76. Resico M. and S. Solari (2016). The Social Market Economy as a Feasible Policy Option for Latin Countries, History of Economic Thought and Policy, 27-52. DOI: 10.3280/SPE2016-002002
  77. Riker W. H. (1987). The Development of American Federalism, Boston, Kluwer Academic.
  78. Roemer J. (1996). Equal Shares, London, Verso.
  79. Röpke W. (1942). International Economic Disintegration, London, Hodge. Röpke W. (1955). Economic Order and International Law, Leiden, Sijthoff.
  80. Röpke W. (1957). Welfare, Freedom and Inflation, London, Pall Mall Press.
  81. Röpke W. ([1954] 1959). International Order and Economic Integration, Dodrecht, Reidel.
  82. Röpke W. (1969). Against the Tide, Vienna, Ludwig von Mises Institute.
  83. Röpke W. ([1950] 1982). Is the German Economic Policy the Right One? In Stützel W.,
  84. C. Watrin, H. Willgerodt and K. Hohmann (eds.), Standard Texts on the Social Market Economy – Two Centuries of Discussion: 37-48, Stuttgart, Fischer.
  85. Röpke W. ([1951] 1989). Interdependence of Domestic and International Economic Systems. In Peacock A. and H. Willgerodt (eds.) (1989b): 68-81.
  86. Röpke W. ([1958] 1998). A Humane Economy, Wilmington, ISI Books.
  87. Röpke W. ([1962] 2000). Europa in der Welt von heute, Zürich, Schulthess.
  88. Röpke W. ([1944] 2002). The Moral Foundation of Civil Society, New Brunswick, Transaction Publishers.
  89. Röpke W. ([1942] 2009). The Social Crisis of Our Time, New Brunswick, Transaction Publishers.
  90. Rosamund B. (2006). The uniting of Europe and the foundation of EU studies, Journal of European Public Policy, 12(5): 237-254. DOI: 10.1080/13501760500043928
  91. Rüstow A. (1942). General Sociological Causes of the Economic Disintegration and Possibilities of Reconstruction, Afterword to Wilhelm Röpke, International Economic Disintegration: 267-83, London, Hodge.
  92. Rüstow A. (1953). Soziale Marktwirtschaft als Gegenprogramm gegen Kommunismus und Bolschewismus. In Hunold, A. (ed.) Wirtschaft ohne Wunder: 97-127, Zürich, Rentsch.
  93. Rüstow A. (1963). Rede und Antwort, Ludwigsburg, Hoch.
  94. Ryner M. (2015). Europe’s Ordoliberal Iron Cage, Journal of European Public Policy, 22(2): 275-94. DOI: 10.1080/13501763.2014.995119
  95. Scheuerman W. (2016). Crises and Extralegality from Above and Below. In Kjaer P.F. and N. Olsen (eds.) Critical Theories of Crisis in Europe: 197-212, London, Rowman & Littlefield.
  96. Schmidt V. (2006). Democracy in Europe, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
  97. Schmitt-Beck R. (2016). The “Alternative für Deutschland in the Electorate”: Between Single-Issue and Right-Wing Populist Party, German Politics, 26(1): 124-148. DOI: 10.1080/09644008.2016.1184650
  98. Sievert O. (1993). Geld, das man nicht selbst herstellen kann: Ein ordnungspolitisches Plädoyer für die Währungsunion. In Bofinger P., S. Collignon and E.-M. Lipp (eds.), Währungsunion oder Währungschaos?: 13-24. Wiesbaden, Gabler.
  99. Sinn H.-W. (2014). The Euro Trap, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
  100. Stiglitz J. (2016). The Euro and Its Threat to the Future of Europe, London, Allen Lane.
  101. Stockhammer E. (2016). Neoliberal growth models, monetary union and the Euro crisis. New Political Economy, 21 (4): 365-379. DOI: 10.1080/13563467.2016.1115826
  102. Streeck W. (2015). Heller, Schmitt and the Euro, European Law Journal, 21(3): 361-70.
  103. Streit M.E. and H. Wohlgemuth (2000). The Market Economy and the State. Hayekian and Ordoliberal Conceptions. In Koslowski P. (ed.) (2010): 224-69.
  104. Tribe K. (1995). Strategies of Economic Order: German Economic Discourse, 1750-1950, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
  105. Vanberg V. (2001). The Constitution of Markets, London, Routledge.
  106. Vanberg V. (2014). Ordnungspolitik. The Freiburg School and the Reason of Rules. Freiburger Diskussionspapiere zur Ordnungsökonomie, 14/01. Accessed 25 November 2016. -- http://www.eucken.de/fileadmin/bilder/Dokumente/DP2014/Diskussionspapier_1401.pdf.
  107. Vanberg V. (2015). Ordoliberalism, Ordnungspolitik and the Reason of Rules, European Review of International Studies, 2 (3): 27–36.
  108. Von Mises L. ([1927]1985). Liberalism in the Classical Tradition, San Francisco, Cobden Press.
  109. Weidmann J. (2014). Vortrag bei der Verleihung des Wolfram-Engels-Preises, Accessed 28
  110. July 2017. -- http://www.bundesbank.de/Redaktion/DE/Reden/2014/2014_03_28_weidmann.html.
  111. White J. (2015). Emergency Europe, Political Studies, 63(2): 300-18. DOI: 10.1111/1467-9248.12072
  112. Wilkinson M. (2013). The Spectre of Authoritarian Liberalism: Reflections on the Constitutional Crisis of the European Union, German Law Journal, 14(5): 527-60.
  113. Wilkinson M. (2015). Authoritarian Liberalism in the European Constitutional Imagination, European Law Journal, 21(3): 313-39.
  114. Willgerodt H. and A. Peacock (1989). German Liberalism and Economic Revival. In Peacock A. and H. Willgerodt (eds.), (1989b): 1-14.
  115. Young B. (2015). Introduction: The Hijacking of German Ordoliberalism, European Review of International Studies, 2(3): 7-15.
  116. Young B. (2017a). Das Hijacking des Ordoliberalismus. In Baden-Badener Unternehmergespräche (ed.) Der Ordoliberalismus: Chance oder Gefahr für Europa?: 71-83, Munich, Goetz.
  117. Young B. (2017b). Is Germany’s and Europe’s Crisis Politics Ordoliberal and/or Neoliberal? In Biebricher T. and F. Vogelmann (eds.) The Birth of Austerity: forthcoming, London: Rowman & Littlefield.

  • Zwischen Pflichten und Fiktionen Aaron Sahr, in Zeitschrift für Soziologie /2019 pp.209
    DOI: 10.1515/zfsoz-2019-0016
  • Ordoliberal ideas on Europe: two paradigms of European economic integration Federico Bruno, in History of European Ideas /2023 pp.737
    DOI: 10.1080/01916599.2022.2151494
  • Modern Monetary Theory, Fiscal Dominance and the European Central Bank Aloys Prinz, Hanno Beck, in Credit and Capital Markets – Kredit und Kapital /2022 pp.431
    DOI: 10.3790/ccm.55.4.431
  • New Culture Wars: Tradwives, Bodybuilders and the Neoliberalism of the Far-Right Felix del Campo, in Critical Sociology /2023 pp.689
    DOI: 10.1177/08969205221109169
  • Greece in the 21st Century Vassilis K. Fouskas, Constantine Dimoulas, pp.1 (ISBN:9781351047524)
  • Ordoliberalism, European Monetary Union and State Power Werner Bonefeld, in Critical Sociology /2019 pp.995
    DOI: 10.1177/0896920519832994
  • Capital Par Excellence: On Money as an obscure thing Werner Bonefeld, in Estudios de Filosofía /2020
    DOI: 10.17533/udea.ef.n62a03

Werner Bonefeld, Stateless Money and State Power: Europe as ordoliberal Ordnungsgefüge in "HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT AND POLICY" 1/2018, pp 5-26, DOI: 10.3280/SPE2018-001001