Between Misery and Reward: The Culture of Vigilance in the Experience of a Venetian Consul during the Early Modern Period

Journal title SOCIETÀ E STORIA
Author/s Umberto Signori
Publishing Year 2022 Issue 2022/177
Language English Pages 20 P. 526-545 File size 259 KB
DOI 10.3280/SS2022-177005
DOI is like a bar code for intellectual property: to have more infomation click here

Below, you can see the article first page

If you want to buy this article in PDF format, you can do it, following the instructions to buy download credits

Article preview

FrancoAngeli is member of Publishers International Linking Association, Inc (PILA), a not-for-profit association which run the CrossRef service enabling links to and from online scholarly content.

Consular participation in state surveillance did not seem to be the basis of the legitimacy of Venetian consuls in Izmir in the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries. Indeed, their activity as informants did not contribute to producing the knowledge that was then used by those in power to make decisions, or to judge and punish illegal behaviour. By placing the Izmir consuls in a broader context in which the state rewarded the participation in a set of specific tasks of as many private individuals as possible, this article reassesses the oftendebated and much-contested efficacy of consular information activity. Rather than providing the Venetian authorities with reliable and indispensable information, this article argues that consular vigilance defined a bond of loyalty and mutual expectations between these consuls and Venice. Far from resulting in superior central control, political power projected its authority onto the narratives and behaviour of consuls and potential informers.

Keywords: culture of vigilance, Venetian consuls, Ottoman Izmir, Republic of Venice, early modern period, state expectations

  1. Allain T. (2015), L’information comme instrument de combat. Le consulat de Jacob van Dam à Smyrne (1668-1688), in Les consuls en Méditerranée, agents d’information (XVI-XXe siecle), sous la direction de S. Marzagalli, Paris, Classiques Garnier, pp. 81-98.
  2. Allain T. (2018), Relations de pouvoirs et enjeux marchands autour du reseau consulaire neerlandais en Méditerranée (XVIIe-XVIIIe siècles), in De l’utilité commerciale des consuls. L’institution consulaire et les marchands dans le monde méditerranéen (XVIIe-XXe siècle), sous la direction de A. Bartolomei, G. Calafat, M. Grenet, J. Ulbert, Rome, Publications de l’École française de Rome, Casa de Velázquez, pp. 421-438.
  3. Anderson S.P. (1989), An English Consul in Turkey. Paul Rycaut at Smyrna, 1667-1678, Oxford, Clarendon Press.
  4. Aragón Ruano A. (2013), Cónsules extranjeros, libertad de comercio y contrabando en los puertos vascos durante la edad Moderna, in Los cónsules de extranjeros en la Edad Moderna y a principios de la Edad Contemporánea, a cura di M. Aglietti, M. Herrero Sánchez, F. Zamora Rodríguez, Aranjuez, Madrid, Doce Calles, pp. 119-129.
  5. Argenti P.P. (1935), The Occupation of Chios by the Venetians, 1694. Described in Contemporary Diplomatic Reports and Official Dispatches, London, John Lane.
  6. Bartolomei A., Calafat G., Grenet M. and Ulbert J. (dir.) (2018), De l’utilité commerciale des consuls. L’institution consulaire et les marchands dans le monde méditerranéen (XVIIe-XXe siècle), Rome, Publications de l’École française de Rome, Casa de Velázquez.
  7. Benetti A. (1688), Osservazioni fatte dal fu dottor Antonio Benetti nel viaggio a Costantinopoli dell’illustriss. et eccellent. sig. Gio. Battista Donado, Venezia, Andrea Poletti.
  8. Beri E. (2013), Informare, rappresentare e assistere. I consoli genovesi nel teatro marittimo ligure-tirrenico durante le guerre di Corsica (1729-1768), in Los cónsules de extranjeros en la Edad Moderna y a principios de la Edad Contemporánea, a cura di M. Aglietti, M. Herrero Sánchez, F. Zamora Rodríguez, Aranjuez, Madrid, Doce Calles, pp. 95-104.
  9. Boogert van den M.H. (2005), The Capitulations and the Ottoman Legal System: Qadis, Consuls and Beratlıs in the 18th Century, Leiden, Brill.
  10. Brendecke A. (2009), Imperium und Empirie: Funktionen des Wissens in der Spanischen Kolonialherrschaft, Köln, Böhlau Verlag Köln.
  11. Brendecke A. (2012), Imperio e información: funciones del saber en el dominio colonial español, Madrid, Frankfurt am Main, Iberoamericana, Vervuert.
  12. Brendecke A. (2016), The Empirical Empire: Spanish Colonial Rule and the Politics of Knowledge, Berlin, De Gruyter Oldenbourg.
  13. Brendecke A. and Molino P. (eds.) (2018), The History and Cultures of Vigilance. Historicizing the Role of Private Attention in Society, in «Storia della Storiografia», vol. 74, n. 2, pp. 11-132.
  14. Brizay F. (2015), Des agents de renseignements. Les membres du personnel consulaire français à Rome, à Naples et en Sicile au début du XVIIIe siècle (1699-1724), in Les consuls en Méditerranée, agents d’information (XVI-XXe siécle), sous la direction de S. Marzagalli, Paris, Classiques Garnier, pp. 141-158.
  15. Buono A. (2020), Archiviare per amministrare? A proposito della produzione e dell’uso della documentazione nell’Impero spagnolo, in Archivi del mondo moderno. Pratiche, conflitti, convergenze, a cura di A. Buono, M. Giuli, Roma, Carocci, pp. 65-95.
  16. Burgh van der A.H.H. (1882), Inventaris van Het Archief van de Directie van de Levantse Handel En de Navigatie in de Middellandse Zee (1614) 1625-1826 (1828), The Hague, Nationaal Archief.
  17. Calafat G. (2015), La contagion des rumeurs. Information consulaire, santé et rivalité commerciale des ports francs (Livourne, Marseille et Génes, 1670-1690), in Les consuls en Méditerranée, agents d’information (XVI-XXe siecle), sous la direction de S. Marzagalli, Paris, Classiques Garnier, pp. 99-119.
  18. Carrino A. (2011a), Fra nazioni e piccole patrie. “Padroni” e mercanti liguri sulle rotte tirreniche del secondo settecento, in «Società e storia», 131, pp. 36-67.
  19. Carrino A. (2011b), Ressources “nationales“ et ressources locales. Les “Génois” sur les routes tyrrhénniennes entre le XVIIIe siècle et début du XIXe siècle, in «The Historical Review/La Revue Historique», 7, pp. 99-125.
  20. Carrino A. (2018), Un console napoletano nel Mediterraneo borbonico: Francisco Hombrados (1755-1765), in De l’utilité commerciale des consuls. L’institution consulaire et les marchands dans le monde méditerranéen (XVIIe-XXe siècle), a cura di A. Bartolomei, G. Calafat, M. Grenet, J. Ulbert, Rome, Publications de l’École française de Rome, Casa de Velázquez, pp. 455-470.
  21. Chardin J. (1983), Voyage de Paris à Ispahan, ed. by S. Yerasimos, vol. 1, De Paris à Tiflis, Paris, La Découverte/Maspero.
  22. Dam van Isselt W.E. (1917), Valsch geld in onze nederzetting in de levant (2e helft der 17e eeuw), in «Bijdragen voor Vaderlandsche Geschiedenis en Oudheidkunde», 5th, 4, pp. 297-308.
  23. De Vivo F. (2018), Archival Intelligence: Diplomatic Correspondence, Information Overload, and Information Management in Italy, 1450–1650, in Archives and Information in the Early Modern World, ed. by K. Peters, A. Walsham, L. Corens, Oxford, Oxford University Press, pp. 53-85.
  24. Denis-Delacour C. (2013), Flying the Pope’s Flag. The Commercial Exploitation of the Roman Flag in Mediterranean Mercantile Policies (18th Century), in «Quaderni storici», 2, pp. 395-417.
  25. Dursteler E.R. (2001), The Bailo in Constantinople: Crisis and Career in Venice’s Early Modern Diplomatic Corps. in «Mediterranean Historical Review», vol. 16, n. 2, pp. 1-30.
  26. Fioriti F. (2013), Battista Durazzo a Smirne (1668–1669): Finanza, commercio e monete false, M.A. thesis, Università degli Studi di Genova.
  27. Ghobrial J.P.A. (2019), Moving Stories and What They Tell Us: Early Modern Mobility Between Microhistory and Global History, in «Past & Present», 242, 14, pp. 243-280.
  28. Greene M. (2010), Catholic Pirates and Greek Merchants: A Maritime History of the Mediterranean, Princeton, Princeton University Press.
  29. Guéna P. and Mazou S. (2019), Fidélité politique et négociation impériale dans le Stato da Mar vénitien: essai d’étude quantitative, 1463-1505, in «Mélanges de l’École Française de Rome – Moyen Age», vol. 131, n. 1.
  30. Gürkan E.S. (2012), The Efficacy of Ottoman Counter-Intelligence in the 16th Century, in «Acta Orientalia Academiae Scientiarum Hungaricae», vol. 65, n. 1, pp. 1-38.
  31. Hasluck F.W. (1905), Notes on Manuscripts in the British Museum Relating to Levant Geography and Travel, in «The Annual of the British School at Athens», 12, pp. 196-215.
  32. Hasluck F.W. (1910), Depopulation in the Aegean Islands and the Turkish Conquest, in «The Annual of the British School at Athens», 17, pp. 151-181.
  33. Heywood C. (2013), Standing on Hasluck’s Shoulders: Another Look at Francesco Lupazzolo and His Aegean Isolario (1638), in Archaeology, Anthropology and Heritage in the Balkans and Anatolia: The Life and Times of F. W. Hasluck (1878-1920), D. Shankland (ed.), Istanbul, Isis Press, vol. 3, pp. 349-375.
  34. Judde de Larivière C. (2008), Naviguer, commercer, gouverner. Économie maritime et pouvoirs à Venise (XVe-XVIe siècles), Leiden-Boston, Brill.
  35. Kadı İ.H. (2012), Ottoman and Dutch Merchants in the Eighteenth Century, Leiden, Brill.
  36. Le Gouic O. (2018), Le consulat de France à Cadix face aux réformes carolines (1765-1788), in De l’utilité commerciale des consuls. L’institution consulaire et les marchands dans le monde méditerranéen (XVIIe-XXe siècle), a cura di A. Bartolomei, G. Calafat, M. Grenet, J. Ulbert, Rome, Publications de l’École française de Rome, Casa de Velázquez, pp. 355-374.
  37. Lo Basso L. (2015), Diaspora e armamento marittimo nelle strategie economiche dei genovesi nella seconda metà del XVII secolo: una storia globale, in «Studi storici», vol. 56, n. 1, pp. 137-155.
  38. Luca C. (2008), Contributi alla biografia dei medici Jacopo Pylarino (1659–1718) e Bartolomeo Ferrati (?–1738), in Vocaţia Istoriei. Prinos Profesorului Şerban Papacostea, a cura di O. Cristea, G. Lazăr, Brăila, Istros Publishing House of the Brăila’s Museum, pp. 635-652.
  39. Magni C. (1692), Quanto di più curioso, e vago ha potuto raccorre Cornelio Magni nel secondo biennio da esso consumato in viaggi, e dimore per la Turchia. In varie lettere scritte in Italia, Parma, Pazzoni e Monti.
  40. Maréchaux B. (2013), Consuls vénitiens en Méditerranée orientale (1575-1645), in Los cónsules de extranjeros en la Edad Moderna y a principios de la Edad Contemporánea, a cura di M. Aglietti, M. Herrero Sánchez, F. Zamora Rodríguez, Aranjuez, Madrid, Doce Calles, pp. 145-157.
  41. Marzagalli S. (dir.) (2015), Les consuls en Méditerranée, agents d’information (XVIe-XXe siècle), Paris Classiques Garnier.
  42. Marzagalli S. and Ulbert J. (dir.) (2019), De l’intérêt d’être consul en Méditerranée, XVIIe-XXe siècle, in «Cahiers de la Méditerranée», 98, pp. 9-177.
  43. Mézin A. (2018), La défense des intérêts des négociants français de Cadix dans la première moitié du XVIIIe siècle d’après la correspondance ministérielle, in De l’utilité commerciale des consuls. L’institution consulaire et les marchands dans le monde méditerranéen (XVIIe-XXe siècle), a cura di A. Bartolomei, G. Calafat, M. Grenet, J. Ulbert, Rome, Publications de l’École française de Rome, Casa de Velázquez, pp. 29-36.
  44. Milani G. (2020), Corruzione, delazione e pubblico interesse. Qualche caso duecentesco dal Liber falsariorum di Padova, in Riferire all’autorità. Denuncia e delazione tra Medioevo ed Età Moderna, a cura di M.G. Muzzarelli, Roma, Viella, pp. 49-62.
  45. Müller L. (2004), Consuls, Corsairs, and Commerce. The Swedish Consular Service and Long-Distance Shipping, 1720-1815, Uppsala, Uppsala Universitet.
  46. Muzzarelli M.G. (a cura di) (2020), Riferire all’autorità. Denuncia e delazione tra Medioevo ed Età Moderna, Roma, Viella.
  47. Olnon M. (2014), “Brought under the Law of the Land”: The History, Demography and Geography of Crossculturalism in Early Modern Izmir, and the Köprülü Project of 1678, Ph.D. diss., Leiden, Leiden University.
  48. Oyen van A.A.V. and Epen van J.D.G. (eds.) (1889), Algemeen Nederlandsch familieblad, vol. 6, Rotterdam, Bureau Groenendaal.
  49. Pastine O. (1952), Genova e l’Impero ottomano nel secolo XVII, Genova, Società ligure di storia patria.
  50. Petitjean J. (2013), L’intelligence des choses : une histoire de l’information entre Italie et Méditerranée (XVIe-XVIIe siècles), Rome, École française de Rome.
  51. Petitjean J. (2015), Gênes et le bon gouvernement de l’information (1665-1670), in Les consuls en Méditerranée, agents d’information (XVI-XXe siecle), sous la direction de S. Marzagalli, Paris, Classiques Garnier, pp. 59-80.
  52. Pialoux A. (2015), Les consuls de l’État ecclésiastique au XVIIIe siècle, au cœur du dispositif d’information de la France à Rome, in Les consuls en Méditerranée, agents d’information (XVI-XXe siecle), sous la direction de S. Marzagalli, Paris, Classiques Garnier, pp. 159-178.
  53. Poumarède G. (2020), L’Empire de Venise et les Turcs XVIe-XVIIe siècle, Paris, Classiques Garnier.
  54. Preto P. (2010), I servizi segreti di Venezia. Spionaggio e controspionaggio ai tempi della Serenissima, Second edition, Milano, Il Saggiatore.
  55. Rycaut P. (1680), The History of the Turkish Empire from the Year 1623 to the Year 1677 Containing the Reigns of the Three Last Emperours, Viz., Sultan Morat or Amurat IV, Sultan Ibrahim, and Sultan Mahomet IV, His Son, the XIII Emperour Now Reigning, London, John Starkey.
  56. Signori U. (2016), Informare e proteggere: la rete consolare veneziana nel mediterraneo orientale (1670-1715), in «RiMe», vol. 17, n. 2, pp. 127-152.
  57. Signori U. (2019), Supplier pour le consulat. Entre défense des intérêts personnels et service fidèle des consuls vénitiens dans le Levant ottoman (1670-1703), in «Cahiers de la Méditerranée», 98, pp. 29-44.
  58. Tolias G. (2017), Shaping the Levant in the 17th Century: Francesco Lupazzolo and His Isolarii (1638), in Izmir from Past to Present: Human and Cultural Interactions, ed. by M. Espagne, R.G. Gürtekin Demir, S. Verger, P. Aydemir, Izmir, Büyükflehir Belediyesi, pp. 422-434.
  59. Trivellato F. (2007), Merchants’ Letters Across Geographical and Social Boundaries, in Correspondence and Cultural Exchange in Europe, 1400-1700, F. Bethencourt, F. Egmond (eds.), Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, pp. 80-103.
  60. Tucci U. (2007), Jacopo Pilarino pioniere dell’innesto del vaiolo, in «Thesaurismata», n. 37, pp. 421-434.
  61. Vallerani M. (2001), I fatti nella logica del processo medievale. Note introduttive, in «Quaderni storici», 3, pp. 665-694.
  62. Vallerani M. (2008), Modelli di verità. Le prove nei processi inquisitori, in L’enquête au moyen âge, sous la direction de C. Gauvard, Rome, École française de Rome, pp. 123-142.
  63. Wilson B. (2013), Francesco Lupazzolo’s Isolario (1638): The Aegean Archipelago and Early Modern Historical Anthropology, in Reflections on Renaissance Venice: A Celebration of Patricia Fortini Brown, ed. by B. De Maria, M. Frank, Milan, Five Continents, pp. 187-199.
  64. Zamora Rodríguez F.J. (2014), «Les François lui ont l’obligation d’avoir favorisé leur commerce pendant la guerre», in «Rives méditerranéennes», 49, pp. 17-33.

Umberto Signori, Between Misery and Reward: The Culture of Vigilance in the Experience of a Venetian Consul during the Early Modern Period in "SOCIETÀ E STORIA " 177/2022, pp 526-545, DOI: 10.3280/SS2022-177005