Critical perspectives on diversity: state of the art and promising avenues for future research

Author/s Patrizia Zanoni
Publishing Year 2014 Issue 2014/134
Language English Pages 15 P. 189-203 File size 111 KB
DOI 10.3280/SL2014-134012
DOI is like a bar code for intellectual property: to have more infomation click here

Below, you can see the article first page

If you want to buy this article in PDF format, you can do it, following the instructions to buy download credits

Article preview

FrancoAngeli is member of Publishers International Linking Association, Inc (PILA), a not-for-profit association which run the CrossRef service enabling links to and from online scholarly content.

This paper makes a state of the art of the international critically oriented scientific research on diversity, a concept that has increasingly come to refer to sociodemographic identities including, among others, gender, ethnicity, age, sexual orientation, and disability in work settings. While theoretically multifarious, critical approaches to diversity share a focus on the interlocking of socio-demographic identities with power dynamics. Such focus distinguishes them markedly from mainstream approaches aiming at understanding the dynamics of diversity in order to deploy it optimally to achieve organizational goals. After a brief discussion of the specificity of the notion of diversity, the author elaborates on the key theoretical tenets of critical perspectives on diversity and themes that are foundational of this tradition of research. She then identifies four avenues for future critically oriented diversity research starting from the main current debates in the field.

Keywords: Diversity, diversity management, critical theory, power, inequality, post-structuralism

  1. Adib A., Guerrier Y. (2003). The interlocking of gender with nationality, race, ethnicity and class: The narratives of women in hotel work. Gender, Work and Organization, 10: 413-432.
  2. Ahmed S. (2007). The language of diversity. Ethnic and Racial Studies, 30: 235-256.
  3. Alvesson M., Hardy C., Harley B. (2008). Reflecting on reflexivity: reflexive textual practices in organization and management theory. Journal of Management Studies, 45: 480-501.
  4. Alvesson M., Willmott H. (1992a). On the idea of emancipation in management and organization studies. Academy of Management Review, 17: 432-464.
  5. Alvesson M., Willmott H. (1992b). Critical Management Studies. London: Sage.
  6. Amason A.C. (1996). Distinguishing the effects of functional and dysfunctional conflict on strategic decision making: resolving a paradox for top management teams. Academy of Management Journal, 39: 123-148.
  7. Nkomo S., Cox T. (1996). Diverse Identities in Organizations. In: Clegg S.R., Hardy C., Nord W.R., a cura di, Handbook of Organization Studies. London: Sage, pp. 338-356.
  8. Anderson B., Ruhs M. (2010). Migrant workers: who needs them? A framework for the analysis of staff shortages, immigration, and public policy. In: Ruhs M., Anderson B., eds., Who Needs Migrant Workers? Labour shortages, immigration, and public policy, pp. 15-56.
  9. Ashcraft K.L. (2013). The glass slipper: ‘incorporating’ occupational identity in management studies. Academy of Management Review, 38: 6-31.
  10. Avent-Holt D., Tomaskovic-Devey D. (2013). A relational theory of earnings inequality. American Behavioral Scientist, 58, 3: 379-399.
  11. Bacchi C., Eveline J. (2009). Gender Mainstreaming or Diversity Mainstreaming? The Politics of “Doing”. Nordic Journal of Feminist and Gender Research, 17: 2-17.
  12. Benschop Y., Dorewaard H. (1998). Covered by equality: the gender subtext of organizations. Organization Studies, 19: 787-805.
  13. Bruni E.A., Gherardi S., Poggio B. (2004). Doing gender, doing entrepreneurship: an ethnographic account of intertwined practices. Gender, Work and Organization, 11: 406-427.
  14. Calás M.B. (1992) An/other silent voice? Representing ‘Hispanic woman’ in organizational texts. In: Mill A.J., Tancred P., a cura di, Gendering Organizational Analysis, pp. 201-21. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
  15. Calás M.B., Smircich L. (1992). Re-writing gender into organizational theorizing: direction from feminist perspectives. In: Reed M.I., Hughes M.D., a cura di, Re-thinking Organization: New Directions in Organizational Research and Analysis, pp. 227-53. London: Sage.
  16. Calás M.B., Smircich L. (2009). Feminist perspectives on gender in organizational research: what is and is yet to be. In: Buchanan D., Bryman A., a cura di, Handbook of Organizational Research Methods. London: Sage.
  17. Cassell C., Biswas R. (2000). Editorial: managing diversity in the new millennium. Personnel Review, 29: 268-273.
  18. Cavendish R. (1982). Women on the Line. London: Routledge.
  19. Chouliaraki L., Fairclough N. (2010). Critical discourse analysis in organizational studies: towards an integrationist methodology. Journal of Management Studies, 47: 1213-1218.
  20. Cockburn C. (1983). Brothers: Male Dominance and Technological Change. London: Pluto.
  21. Dick P., Cassell C. (2002). Barriers to managing diversity in a UK police constabulary: the role of discourse. Journal of Management Studies, 39: 953-76.
  22. Edelman L.B. (1992). Legal ambiguity and symbolic structures: organizational mediation of civil rights law. American Journal of Sociology, 97: 1531-1576.
  23. Edelman L.B., Riggs Fuller S.R., Mara-Drita I. (2001). Diversity rhetoric and the managerialization of the law. American Journal of Sociology, 106: 1589-1641.
  24. Esping-Andersen G. (2002). Chapter 3: A new gender contract. In: Esping-Andersen G., a cura di, Why we Need a new Welfare State. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 68-95.
  25. Fairclough N. (1992). Discourse and Social Change. Cambridge: Polity Press. Fairclough N., Wodak R. (1997). Critical discourse analysis. In: T. van Dijk, a cura di, Discourse as social interaction: Discourse studies, vol. 2 (pp. 258-284). London: Sage.
  26. Fournier V., Grey C. (2000). At the critical moment: conditions and prospects for critical management studies. Human Relations, 53(1): 7-32.
  27. Gherardi S. (1994). The gender we think, the gender we do in our everyday organizational lives. Human Relations, 47: 591-610. Gibson-Graham J.-K. (1996). Queer(y)ing Capitalist Organization. Organization, 3: 541-545.
  28. Hamde K., Janssens M., Van Laer K., Wahlin N., Zanoni P. (2011). Diversity and diversity management in business and organizational studies. In: Knotter S., De Lobel R., Tsipouri L., Stenius, V. a cura di, Diversity Research and Policy: A Multidisciplinary Exploration. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press, pp. 159-179.
  29. Healy S., Traversing fantasies, activating desires: economic geography, activist research and psychoanalytic methodology. Professional Geographer, 62(4): 496-506.
  30. Hearn J. (1996). Deconstructing the dominant: making the one(s) the other(s). Organization, 3: 611-626.
  31. Kalev A., Dobbin F., Kelly E. (2006). Best practices or best guesses? Assessing the efficacy of corporate affirmative action and diversity policies. American Sociological Review, 71: 589-617.
  32. Kärreman D., Alvesson M. (2004). Cages in tandem: management control, social identity, and identification in a knowledge-intensive firm. Organization, 11: 149-175.
  33. Klarsfeld A., a cura di (2010). International Handbook on Diversity Management at Work: Country Perspectives on Diversity and Equal Treatment. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
  34. Klarsfeld A., ed. (2010). International Handbook on Diversity Management at Work: Country Perspectives on Diversity and Equal Treatment. Edward Elgar.
  35. Kulik C.T., Roberson L. (2008). Common goals and missed opportunities: a research agenda for diversity education in academic and organizational settings. Academy of Management Learning & Education, 7: 371-375.
  36. Janssens M., Zanoni P. (2005). Many diversities for many services: theorizing diversity (management) in service companies. Human Relations, 58: 311-340.
  37. Janssens M., Zanoni P. (in press). Alternative diversity management: organizational practices fostering ethnic equality at work. Scandinavian Journal of Management.
  38. Jones D., Pringle J., Shepherd D. (2000). “Managing diversity” meets Aotearoa/New Zealand. Personnel Review, 29: 364-380.
  39. Liff S., Wajcman J. (1996). ‘Sameness’ and ‘difference’ revisited: which way forward for equal opportunity initiatives? Journal of Management Studies, 33: 79-94.
  40. Linnehan R., Konrad A.M. (1999). Diluting diversity: implications for intergroup inequality in organizations. Journal of Management Inquiry, 8: 399-414.
  41. Litvin D.R. (1997). The discourse of diversity: from biology to management. Organization, 4: 187-209.
  42. Lorbiecki A., Jack G. (2000). Critical turns in the evolution of diversity management. British Journal of Management, 11: S17-S31.
  43. Mercurio R., Pezzillo Iacono M. (2009). Costruzione delle Diversita, Regolazione delle Identita e Controllo Organizzativo. In: Santucci R., Natullo G., Esposito
  44. V., Saracini P., a cura di), “Diversità” Culturali e di Genere nel Lavoro tra Tutele e Valorizzazione. Milano: FrancoAngeli, pp. 78-86.
  45. Milkman R. (1987). Gender at Work: The Dynamics of Job Segregation by Sex During World War II. Champaign, Ill.: University of Illinois Press. Milliken F.J., Martins L.L. (1996). Searching for common threads: understanding the multiple effects of diversity in organizational groups. Academy of Management Review, 21: 402-433.
  46. Nkomo S.M. (2009). The sociology of race: the contributions of W.E.B. DuBois. In: Adler P., a cura di, The Oxford Handbook of Sociology and Organization Studies: Classical Foundations. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  47. Nkomo S. (1992). The emperor has no clothes: rewriting “race into organizations”. Academy of Management Review, 17: 487-513.
  48. Nkomo S., Stewart M. (2006). Diverse Identities in Organizations. In: Clegg S., Hardy C., Lawrence T., Nord W., a cura di, The Sage Handbook of Organizational Studies. London: Sage, pp. 520-540.
  49. Noon M. (2007). The fatal flaws of diversity and the business case for ethnic minorities. Work, Employment and Society, 21: 773-784.
  50. Nyambegera S.M. (2002). Ethnicity and human resource management practice in sub-Saharan Africa: the relevance of the managing diversity discourse. International Journal of Human Resource Management, 13: 1077-1090.
  51. Ogbonna E., Harris L.C. (2006). The dynamic of employee relationships in an ethnically diverse workforce. Human Relations, 59: 379-407.
  52. Okhuysen G.A., Lepak D., Ashcraft K.L., Labianca G., Smith V., Steensma J.K.
  53. (2013). Theories of work and working today. Academy of Management Review, 38: 491-502.
  54. Ortlieb R., Sieben B. (2008). Diversity strategies focused on employees with a migration background: An empirical investigation based on resource dependence theory. Management Revue, 19: 70-93.
  55. Ortlieb R., Sieben B. (2013). Employment strategies and business logic: why do companies employ ethnic minorities? Group & Organization Management, 38: 480-511.
  56. Özbilgin M., Tatli A. (2011). Mapping out the field of equality and diversity: Rise of individualism and voluntarism. Human Relations, 64: 1229-1253.
  57. Phillips N., Oswick C. (2012). Organizational discourse: domains, debates, and directions. The Academy of Management Annals, 6: 435-481.
  58. Poggio B. (2006). Editorial: Outline of a theory of gender practices. Gender, Work and Organization, 13: 225-233.
  59. Prasad P., Mills A. (1997). From showcase to shadow: understanding the dilemmas of managing workplace diversity. In: Prasad P., Mills A., Elmes M., Prasad A., eds., Managing the Organizational Melting Pot, Dilemmas of Workplace Diversity. Sage: Thousand Oaks, pp. 3-27.
  60. Prasad P., Pringle J., Konrad A. (2006). Examining the contours of workplace diversity: concepts, contexts and Cchallenges. In: Konrad A.M., Prasad P., Pringle
  61. J.K., eds., Handbook of Workplace Diversity. London: Sage, pp. 1-22.
  62. Roulstone A., Williams J. (2014). Being disabled, being a manager: ‘glass partitions’ and conditional identities in the contemporary workplace. Disability & Society, 29: 16-29.
  63. Slay H.S., Smith D.A. (2011). Professional identity construction: using narrative to understand the negotiation of professional and stigmatized cultural identities. Human Relations, 64: 85-107 Spicer A., Alvesson M., Kärreman D. (2009). Critical performativity: the unfinished business of Critical Management Studies. Human Relations, 62: 537-560.
  64. Tajfel H. (1982). Social Identity and Intergroup Relations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  65. Tatli A. (2011). A multi-layered exploration of the diversity management field: diversity discourses, practices and practitioners in the UK. British Journal of Management, 22: 238-253.
  66. Tatli A., Özbilgin M. (2012). An emic approach to intersectional study of diversity at work: A Bourdieuan framing. International Journal of Management Reviews, 13: 177-198.
  67. Tilly C. (1989). Durable Inequality. Berkley: University of California Press. van den Brink M., Benschop Y. (in press). Practicing gender in academic networking: the role of gatekeepers in professorial recruitment. Journal of Management Studies.
  68. Van Knippenberg D., Schippers M. (2007). Work group diversity. Annual Review of Psychology, 58: 515-541.
  69. Van Laer K., Janssens M. (2011). Ethnic minority professionals’ experience with subtle discrimination at the workplace. Human Relations, 64: 1203-1227.
  70. Williams K.Y., O’Reilly C.A. III (1998). Demography and diversity in organizations: a review of 40 years of research. In: Staw B.M., Cummings L.L., eds., Research in Organizational Behavior. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
  71. Wilson E.M., Iles P. (1999). Managing siversity – an employment and service delivery challenge. International Journal of Public Sector Management, 12: 27-48.
  72. Woodhams C., Corby S. (2007). Then and now: disability legislation and employers’ practices in the UK. British Journal of Industrial Relations, 45: 556-580.
  73. Zanoni P. (2011). Diversity in the lean automobile factory: doing class through gender, disability and age. Organization, 18: 105-127.
  74. Zanoni P. (2013). The ‘dark’ business case for diversity: on the commoditized habitus, value claims and the superior exploitation of subordinate socio-demographic groups. Rethinking Marxism Conference, University of Boston at Amherst, USA, September 19-22.
  75. Zanoni P., Janssens M. (2004). Deconstructing difference: the rhetoric of human resource managers’ diversity discourses. Organization Studies, 25: 55-74.
  76. Zanoni P., Janssens M. (2007). Minority employees engaging with (diversity) management: an analysis of control, agency, and micro-emancipation. Journal of Management Studies, 44: 1371-1397.
  77. Zanoni P., Janssens M. (2012). Bringing work back in: Multiple discourses of diversity in identity work at AutoMotive. 7th Organization Studies Summer Workshop Organisations as Spaces of Work, Rhodes, May 23-26.
  78. Zanoni P., Van Laer K. (in press). Collecting narratives and writing stories of diversity: reflecting on power and identity in our professional practice. In: Bendl
  79. R., Bleijenbergh I., Henttonen E., Mills A.J., a cura di, Oxford Handbook of Diversity. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Patrizia Zanoni, Critical perspectives on diversity: state of the art and promising avenues for future research in "SOCIOLOGIA DEL LAVORO " 134/2014, pp 189-203, DOI: 10.3280/SL2014-134012