Interpretations of Spinoza’s Ontology in Soviet philosophical Historiography in the 1950-70s

Titolo Rivista RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA
Autori/Curatori Iva Manova
Anno di pubblicazione 2016 Fascicolo 2016/1
Lingua Inglese Numero pagine 23 P. 69-91 Dimensione file 557 KB
DOI 10.3280/SF2016-001004
Il DOI è il codice a barre della proprietà intellettuale: per saperne di più clicca qui

Qui sotto puoi vedere in anteprima la prima pagina di questo articolo.

Se questo articolo ti interessa, lo puoi acquistare (e scaricare in formato pdf) seguendo le facili indicazioni per acquistare il download credit. Acquista Download Credits per scaricare questo Articolo in formato PDF

Anteprima articolo

FrancoAngeli è membro della Publishers International Linking Association, Inc (PILA)associazione indipendente e non profit per facilitare (attraverso i servizi tecnologici implementati da CrossRef.org) l’accesso degli studiosi ai contenuti digitali nelle pubblicazioni professionali e scientifiche

The aim of this article is to bring into focus the existence of two methodologically divergent tendencies in what George Kline denotes as «Soviet Spinoza scholarship» and to draw a line of differentiation between them. In particular, it aims to define on the one hand the instrumental interpretations of Spinozism, that is Spinoza’s presence in Soviet philosophy properly speaking, and on the other its historiographical interpretations, that is Spinoza’s presence in Soviet philosophical historiography. The author addresses specifically the readings of Spinoza’s ontology and tries to trace the process of the «emancipation» of Soviet philosophical historiography of this subject from what may be called «Georgi Plekhanov’s heritage». In addition, she analyses Vasilij V. Sokolov’s reading of the doctrine of substance in Spinoza and outlines his contribution to the advance of high-standard historicalphilosophical studies in the Soviet Union.

Keywords:Philosophical historiography, Soviet philosophy, Spinoza, substance, ontology.

  1. L. Kline, in George L. Kline (ed.), Spinoza in Soviet Philosophy. A Series of Essays Selected and Translated and with an Introduction, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London 1952, pp. 61-89 (a translation of Ljubov’ I. Aksel’rod, Spinoza i Materializm, ≪Krasnaja nov’≫, 7 (1925), pp. 144-168).
  2. - Bakhurst 1991: David Bakhurst, Consciousness and Revolution in Soviet Philosophy. From the Bolsheviks to Evald Ilyenkov, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1991.
  3. - Ballestrem 1965: Karl Graf von Ballestrem, Review of the chapter by E. Ja. Basin, Opredelenie ponjatija ‘materija’ v dialektičeskom materializme i ego buržuaznye ‘kritiki’ of Mikhail T. Jovčuk, Victor A. Malinin (eds.), Protiv sovremennyx buržuaznyx fal’sifikatorov marksistko-leninskoj filosofii, Nauka, Moskva 1965, pp. 84-100, ≪Studies in Soviet Thought≫, V, 4 (December 1965), pp. 325-326.
  4. - Belen’kij 1964: Moisej S. Belen’kij, Spinoza, Molodaja gvardija, Moskva 1964.
  5. - Blakeley 1975: Thomas J. Blakeley (ed.), Themes in Soviet Marxist Philosophy. Selected Articles from the ‘Filosofskaja Enciklopedija’, Reidel, Dodrecht 1975 (Sovietica, 37).
  6. - Deborin 1952: Abram M. Deborin, Spinoza’s World-View, tr. George L. Kline, in George L. Kline (ed.), Spinoza in Soviet Philosophy. A Series of Essays Selected and Translated and with an Introduction, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London 1952, pp. 90-119 (a translation of Abram M. Deborin, Mirovozzrenie Spinozy, ≪Vestnik kommunističeskoj akademii≫, 20 (1927), pp. 5-29).
  7. - Dynnik et al. 1972: Mikhail A. Dynnik et al. (eds.), Istorija antičnoj dialektiki, Mysl’, Moskva 1972.
  8. - Goerdt 1960: Wilhelm Goerdt, Fragen der Philosophie: ein Materialbeitrag zur Erforschung der Sowjetphilosophie im Spiegel der Zeitschrift ≪Voprosy filosofii≫ 1947-1956, Westdeutscher Verlag, Koln 1960.
  9. - Gropp 1967: Rugard Otto Gropp, Uber eine unhaltbare Konzeption, ≪Deutsche Zeitschrift fur Philosophie≫, XV (1967), 9, pp. 1092-1104. - Ilyenkov 1997: Evald V. Ilyenkov, K dokladu o Spinoze: Doklad na zasedanii sektora dialektičeskogo materializma Instituta filosofii AN SSSR (sentjabr’ 1965 g.) v svjazi s gotovivšimsja izdaniem ≪Istorii dialektiki≫, in Valentin I. Tolstyh (ed.), Drama sovetskoj filosofii. Evald Vasilevič Ilyenkov (Kniga-dialig), IFRAN, Moskva 1997, pp. 170-182.
  10. - Ilyenkov 1999: Id., Spinoza (materialy k knige), ed. by Aleksandr G. Novohat’ko, in Vladislav A. Lektorskij (ed.), E.V. Ilyenkov: Ličnost’ i tvorčestvo, Jazyki russkoj kul’tury, Moskva 1999, pp. 201-244.
  11. - Ilyenkov 1977: Id., Dialectical Logic. Essays on Its History and Theory, tr. Herbert Campbell Creighton, Progress Publishers, Moscow 1977 (the Russian edition is of 1974; the 1977 English edition had a revised and expanded 2nd ed. in 1984).
  12. - Jovčuk 1960: Mikhail T. Jovčuk, G.V. Plekhanov i ego trudy po istorii filosofii, Izdatel’stvo sozial’no-ekonomičeskoj literatury, Moskva 1960.
  13. - Kamenskij, Narskij, Ojzerman 1974: Zakhar A. Kamenskij, Igor’ S. Narskij, Teodor I. Ojzerman (eds.), Istorija dialektiki XIV-XVIII vv., Mysl’, Moskva 1974.
  14. - Kedrov 1964: Bonifatij Kedrov, Materialism, in Filosofskaja enciklopedija, vol. III, Sovetskaja enciklopedija, Moskva 1964, pp. 343-358.
  15. - Kline 1952: George L. Kline, Introduction, in Id. (ed.), Spinoza in Soviet Philosophy. A Series of Essays Selected and Translated and with an Introduction, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London 1952, pp. 1-47.
  16. - Kline 1961: Id., Spinoza East and West: Six Recent Studies in Spinozist Philosophy, ≪The Journal of Philosophy≫, LVIII (1961), 13, pp. 346-355.
  17. - Konikov 1965: Iosif A. Konikov, Cennoe issledovanie filosofii Spinozy: V.V. Sokolov, Filosofija Spinozy i sovremennost’, MGU, 1964, 450 str., ≪Voprosy filosofii≫, (XIX) 1965, 8, pp. 166-169.
  18. - Konikov 1971: Id., Materialism Spinozy, Nauka, Moskva 1971.
  19. - Lenin 1972: Vladimir I. Lenin, Materialism and Empirio-Criticism, tr. Abraham Fineberg, in Lenin Collected Works, Progress Publishers, Moscow 1972, vol. XIV, pp. 17-362.
  20. - Levant 2012: Alex Levant, E.V. Ilyenkov and Creative Soviet Theory: An Introduction to ‘Dialectics of the Ideal’, ≪Historical Materialism≫, XX (2012), 2, pp. 125-148.
  21. - Lukanin 1974: Ratimir K. Lukanin, Sovetskaja istoriografija zapadnoevropejskoj dialektiki XIV-XVIII vv. [Sovietic Philosophical Historiography of West European Dialectics in 14th-18th century], in Zakhar A. Kamenskij, Igor’ S. Narskij, Teodor I. Ojzerman (eds.), Istorija dialektiki XIV-XVIII vv., Mysl’, Moskva 1974, pp. 289-324.
  22. - Maidansky 2003: Andrey Maidansky, The Russian Spinozists, ≪Studies in East European Thought≫, LV (2003), pp. 199-216.
  23. - Majdanskij 2002: Id., Ponjatie myšlenija u Il’enkova i Spinozy, ≪Voprosy filosofii≫, LV (2002), 8, pp. 163-173.
  24. - Mareev 2007: Sergej Mareev, Spinoza v sovetskoj filosofii, ≪Logos≫, XVII (2007), 2, pp. 187-221 [pp. 209-221 contains a rich bibliography of texts by and on Spinoza in Russian].
  25. - Meltov 2007: Vladimir I. Meltov, Spinoza dans la philosophie russe, in Andre Tosel, Pierre-Francois Moreau, Jean Salem (eds.), Spinoza au XIXe siecle. Actes des journees d’etudes organisees a la Sorbonne 9 et 16 mars, 23 et 30 novembre 1977, Publications de la Sorbonne, Paris 2007, pp. 377-386.
  26. - Mitin 1932: Mark B. Mitin, Spinoza i dialektičeskij materialism, ≪Pod znamenem marksizma≫, XI (1932), 11-12, pp. 153-179. - Morfino 2002: Vittorio Morfino, Causa sui o Wechselwirkung: Engels tra Spinoza e Hegel, in Id., Incursioni spinoziste, Mimesis, Milano 2002, pp. 57-82 (originally published in: Mario Cingoli (a cura di), Friedrich Engels cent’anni dopo. Ipotesi per un bilancio critico, Teti, Milano 1998, pp. 120-147).
  27. - Morfino 2011: Id., Marx e Spinoza, in Mario Cingoli, Vittorio Morfino (a cura di), Aspetti del pensiero di Marx e delle interpretazioni successive, Edizioni Unicopli, Milano 2011, pp. 83-109.
  28. - Narskij 1974: Igor’ S. Narskij, Zapadno-evropejskaja filosofija XVII veka, Vysšaja škola, Mosva 1974.
  29. - Ojzerman, Bogomolov 1987: Teodor I. Ojzerman, Aleksej S. Bogomolov (eds.), Istorija dialektiki. Nemeckaja klassičeskaja filosofija, Mysl’, Moskva 1987.
  30. - Oittinen 2005: Vesa Oittinen, Evald Ilyenkov as an Interpreter of Spinoza, ≪Studies in East European Thought≫, LVII (2005), 3-4, pp. 319-338.
  31. - Planty-Bonjour 1967: Guy Planty-Bonjour, The Categories of Dialectical Materialism, Reidel, Dordrecht 1967, (Sovietica, 24).
  32. - Plekhanov 1976: Georgi Plekhanov, Fundamental Problems of Marxism, in Selected Philosophical Works, Volume 3, Progress Publishers, Moscow 1976, pp. 117-83.
  33. - Rapp 1965: Friedrich Rapp, V.V. Sokolov: Filosofija Spinozy i sovremennost’ (The Philosophy of Spinoza and the Present day). MGU 1964, 450 s., ≪Studies in Soviet Thought≫, V (1965), 4, pp. 333-335.
  34. - Salem 2007: Jean Salem, Georges Plekhanov, lecteur de Spinoza, in Andre Tosel, Pierre-Francois Moreau, Jean Salem (eds.), Spinoza au XIXe siecle. Actes des journees d’etudes organisees a la Sorbonne 9 et 16 mars, 23 et 30 novembre 1977, Publications de la Sorbonne, Paris 2007, pp. 149-160.
  35. - Seidel 1966: Helmut Seidel, Vom praktischen und theoretischen Verhaltniss der Menschen zur Wirklichkeit, ≪Deutsche Zeitschrift fur Philosophie≫, XIV (1966), 10, pp. 1177-1191.
  36. - Sokolov 1955: Vasilij V. Sokolov, Etičeskie i sociologičeskie vozzrenija Spinozy, ≪Voprosy filosofii≫, IX (1955), 3, pp. 59-72.
  37. - Sokolov 1957: Id., Mirovozzrenie Benedikta Spinozy [Benedict Spinoza’s World View], in Benedict Spinoza, Izbrannye proizvedenija, ed. V.V. Sokolov, 2 vols., Izdatel’stvo Političeskoj Literatury, Moskva 1957, vol. I, pp. 5-66.
  38. - Sokolov 1958: Vasilij V. Sokolov, Materializmat v Holandija prez 17 vek i Spinoza [Philosophical Materialism in the Netherlands in the 17th Century, and Spinoza], in Mikhail A. Dynnik, Mikhail T. Jovčuk, Bonifatij M. Kedrov, Mark B. Mitin, Orest V. Trakhtenberg (eds.), Istorija na filosofijata, vol. I, Izdatelstvo na BKP, Sofia 1958 (a Bulgarian translation of the Russian edition: Istorija filosofii, vol. I, Nauka, Moskva 1957), pp. 397-411.
  39. - Sokolov 1964: Id., Filosofija Spinozy i sovremennost’, MGU, Moskva 1964.
  40. - Sokolov 1970: Id., Spinoza, in Filosofskaja enciklopedija, vol. V, Sovetskaja enciklopedija, Moskva 1970, pp. 112-115.
  41. - Sokolov 1974: Id., Spinoza, in Kamenskij, Narskij, Ojzerman 1974, pp. 151-175.
  42. - Sokolov 1977: Id., Spinoza, Mysl’, Moskva 19772 (first ed. 1973).
  43. - Sokolov 1984: Id., Evropejskaja filosofija XV-XVII vekov, Vysšaja škola, Moskva 1984.
  44. - Steila 1991: Daniela Steila, Genesis and Development of Plekhanov’s Theory of Knowledge. A Marxist Between Anthropological Materialism and Physiology, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht 1991 (Sovietica, 55).
  45. - Steila 1996: Ead., Scienza e rivoluzione. La recezione dell’empiriocriticismo nella
  46. cultura russa (1877-1910), Le Lettere, Torino 1996. - Tosel 1993: Andre Tosel, Des usages ≪marxistes≫ de Spinoza, in Olivier Bloch (ed.)
  47. Spinoza au XXe siecle, PUF, Paris 1993, pp. 515-525.
  48. - Tosel 1994: Id., Du materialisme de Spinoza, Kime, Paris 1994.
  49. - Tosel 2007: Id., Pour une etude systematique du rapport de Marx a Spinoza.
  50. Remarques et hypotheses, in Andre Tosel, Pierre-Francois Moreau, Jean Salem (eds.), Spinoza au XIXe siecle. Actes des journees d’etudes organisees a la Sorbonne 9 et 16 mars, 23 et 30 novembre 1977, Publications de la Sorbonne, Paris 2007, pp. 127-147.
  51. - Van der Zweerde 1997: Evert van der Zweerde, Soviet Historiography of Philosophy: Istoriko-filosofskaja nauka, Kluwer, Dordrecht-Boston-London 1997 (Sovietica, 57).
  52. - Yakhot 2012: Yehoshua Yakhot, The Suppression of Philosophy in the USSR (The 1920s & 1930s), tr. by Federick S. Choate, Mehring Books, Oak Park 2012 (original title: Podavlenie filosofii v SSSR (20-30 gody), Chalidze Publications, New York 1981).
  53. - Zapata 1993: Rene Zapata, Spinoza en URSS, in Olivier Bloch (ed.), Spinoza au XXe siecle. Actes des journees d’etudes, les 14 et 21 janvier, 11 et 18 mars 1990 a la Sorbonne, PUF, Paris 1993, pp. 495-498.

  • AKSELROD VE DEBORİN: SPİNOZA’NIN AKOZMİZMİ ÜZERİNE BİR POLEMİK Barışcan Demir, in FLSF Felsefe ve Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi /2024 pp.127
    DOI: 10.53844/flsf.1481099

Iva Manova, Interpretations of Spinoza’s Ontology in Soviet philosophical Historiography in the 1950-70s in "RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA" 1/2016, pp 69-91, DOI: 10.3280/SF2016-001004