Integrated reporting: Much ado about nothing?

Author/s Brigitte de Graaff, Bert Steens, Kees Camfferman
Publishing Year 2021 Issue 2021/2
Language English Pages 42 P. 119-160 File size 829 KB
DOI 10.3280/FR2021-002004
DOI is like a bar code for intellectual property: to have more infomation click here

Below, you can see the article first page

If you want to buy this article in PDF format, you can do it, following the instructions to buy download credits

Article preview

FrancoAngeli is member of Publishers International Linking Association, Inc (PILA), a not-for-profit association which run the CrossRef service enabling links to and from online scholarly content.

Integrated reporting, which helps companies to share their value creation pro-cesses with their stakeholders, has developed rapidly in recent years. Due to the increased attention paid to the International Integrated Reporting Framework is-sued by the International Integrated Reporting Council, the number of companies worldwide engaging in integrated reporting is continually rising, which is presuma-bly driven by the claimed benefits of this practice. Through recourse to legitimacy theory and management fashion theory, here we provide a preliminary assessment of the development of integrated reporting, alongside considering the potential in-fluence of academic research in its growth. We review the existing body of aca-demic literature on this topic, ultimately identifying 123 claims about the benefits of IR from 29 papers published in 15 journals between May 2011 and September 2016, before proceeding to analyse both the sources and the level of substantia-tion of these claims. Our findings suggest that only a few of the purported ad-vantages of integrated reporting are supported by actual empirical evidence, while most of the claims only cite a limited number of primary sources. Based on these results and our assessment of the development of the concept of IR, we propose a future research agenda.

Keywords: integrated reporting, integrated thinking, management fashion, legiti-macy theory, literature review, source analysis.

  1. Abrahamson E. (1996), Management fashion,Academy of management review, 21(1), pp. 254-285, DOI: 10.2307/258636
  2. Abrahamson E. (1991), Managerial fads and fashions: The diffusion and rejection of innovations, Academy of Management Review, 16(3), pp. 586-612,
  3. Adams S., Fries K. and Simnett R. (2011), The journey toward Integrated Reporting, Accountants Digest, 558, pp. 1-41.
  4. Adams S., and Simnett R. (2011), Integrated Reporting: An opportunity for Australia’s not‐for‐profit sector, Australian Accounting Review, 21(3), pp. 292-301,
  5. Atkins J., Atkins B.C., Thomson I. and Maroun W. (2015), “Good” news from nowhere: imagining utopian sustainable accounting, Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal, 28(5), pp. 651-670,
  6. Ballou B., Casey R.J., Grenier J.H. and Heitger D.L. (2012), Exploring the strategic integration of sustainability initiatives: Opportunities for accounting research, Accounting Horizons, 26(2), pp. 265-288,
  7. Bavagnoli F., Comoli M., Gelmini L. and Riva P. (2014), An Open Question in the Integrated Reporting: Materiality or Conciseness?, Working Paper, SSRN,
  8. Beattie V., and Smith S.J. (2013), Value creation and business models: Refocusing the intellectual capital debate, The British Accounting Review, 45(4), pp. 243-254,
  9. Benders J. and van Veen K. (2001), What's in a fashion? Interpretative viability and management fashions, Organization, 8(1), pp. 33-53,
  10. Bitektine A. and Haack P. (2015), The “macro” and the “micro” of legitimacy: toward a multilevel theory of the legitimacy process, Academy of Management Review, 40(1), pp. 49-75,
  11. Brown J., and Dillard J. (2014), Integrated reporting: On the need for broadening out and opening up, Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal, 27(7), pp. 1120-1156,
  12. Burritt R.L. (2012), Environmental performance accountability: planet, people, profits, Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal, 25(2), pp. 370-405, DOI: 10.1108/09513571211198791.
  13. Busco C., Frigo M.L., Quattrone P. and Riccaboni A. (2013). Integrated reporting. Concepts and Cases that Redefine Corporate Accountability. (New York: Springer), DOI: 10.1007/978-3-319-02168-3_1
  14. Cheng M., Green W., Conradie P., Konishi N. and Romi A. (2014), The International Integrated Reporting Framework: Key Issues and Future Research Opportunities, Journal of International Financial Management and Accounting, 25(1), pp. 90-119,
  15. Chiucchi M. S., Montemari M., & Gatti M. (2018), The influence of integrated reporting on management control systems: A case study, International Journal of Business and Management, 13(7), pp. 19-32,
  16. Corbin J.M., and Strauss A.L. (2008), Basics of qualitative research: Techniques and procedures for developing grounded theory. (Los Angeles, Ca: SAGE Publications), DOI: 10.4135/9781452230153
  17. De Beer F., and Du Toit D.H. (2015), Human resources managers as custodians of the King III code, South African Journal of Economic and Management Sciences, 18(2), pp. 206-217,
  18. De Villiers C., Rinaldi L. and Unerman J. (2014), Integrated Reporting: Insights, gaps and an agenda for future research, Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal, 27(7), pp. 1042-1067,
  19. Doeleman H. J., ten Have S. and Ahaus C.T.B. (2014), Empirical evidence on applying the European Foundation for Quality Management Excellence Model, a literature review, Total Quality Management and Business Excellence, 25(5-6), pp. 439-460, DOI: 10.1080/14783363.2013.862916
  20. Dragu I. M., and Tiron-Tudor A. (2013), The integrated reporting initiative from an institutional perspective: emergent factors, Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, 92, pp. 275-279,
  21. Dumay J., and Garanina T. (2013), Intellectual capital research: a critical examination of the third stage, Journal of Intellectual Capital, 14(1), pp. 10-25, DOI: 10.1108/14691931311288995
  22. Dumitru M., Glavan M.E., Gorgan C. and Dumitru V.F. (2013), International integrated reporting framework: a case study in the software industry, Annales Universitatis Apulensis: Series Oeconomica, 15(1), p. 24.
  23. Eccles R. G. and Armbrester K. (2011), Integrated reporting in the cloud, IESE Insight, 8(1), pp. 13-20,
  24. Eccles R. G. and Krzus M.P. (2011), A chronology of integrated reporting, Harvard Business School Accounting and Management Unit Case, 411-049.
  25. Eccles R. G., and Krzus M.P. (2010), One report: Integrated reporting for a sustainable strategy. (New Jersey: John Wiley and Sons).
  26. EY (2012), Excellence in integrated reporting awards, retrieved 3 January 2017, -- from -reporting-awards-2012/$FILE/EY-excellence-in-integrated-reporting-awards-2012.pdf.
  27. Flower J. (2015), The international integrated reporting council: a story of failure, Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 27, pp. 1-17,
  28. Frías‐Aceituno J. V., Rodríguez‐Ariza L. and Garcia‐Sánchez I.M. (2014), Explanatory factors of integrated sustainability and financial reporting, Business strategy and the environment, 23(1), pp. 56-72,
  29. Frías‐Aceituno J. V., Rodríguez‐Ariza L. and Garcia‐Sánchez I.M. (2013a), The role of the board in the dissemination of integrated corporate social reporting, Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management, 20(4), pp. 219-233,
  30. Frías‐Aceituno J. V., Rodríguez‐Ariza L. and Garcia‐Sánchez I.M. (2013b), Is integrated reporting determined by a country's legal system? An exploratory study, Journal of Cleaner Production, 44, pp. 45-55,
  31. Garcia-Sánchez I. M., Rodríguez-Ariza L. and Frías-Aceituno J.V. (2013), The cultural system and integrated reporting, International Business Review, 22(5), pp. 828-838,
  32. Guthrie J., Manes-Rossi F., & Orelli R. L. (2017), Integrated reporting and integrated thinking in Italian public sector organisations, Meditari Accountancy Research, 25(4), pp. 553-573, DOI: 10.1108/MEDAR-06-2017-0155
  33. Hahn R., and Kühnen M. (2013), Determinants of sustainability reporting: a review of results, trends, theory, and opportunities in an expanding field of research, Journal of Cleaner Production, 59, pp. 5-21,
  34. Higgins C., Stubbs W. and Love T. (2014), Walking the talk (s): Organisational narratives of integrated reporting, Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal, 27(7), pp. 1090-1119,
  35. International Integrated Reporting Council (2015), The Integrated Reporting Journey: The Inside Story, retrieved 3 January 2017, -- from http://integratedreporting. org/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/The-Integrated-Reporting-journey-the-inside-story.pdf.
  36. International Integrated Reporting Council (2014a), ‘<IR> Yearbook 2014’, retrieved 3 January 2017, -- from 2014/timeline-assets/timeline.html.
  37. International Integrated Reporting Council (2014b), ‘Tomorrow’s Business Success’, retrieved 3 January 2017, -- from uploads/2014/10/Tomorrows-Business-Success_Integrated-Reporting-L-Oct-2014. pdf.
  38. International Integrated Reporting Council (2013a), IIRC Pilot Programme Yearbook 2013: Business and Investors Explore the Sustainability Perspective, retrieved 3 January 2017, -- from
  39. International Integrated Reporting Council (2013b), The international integrated reporting framework. (London: IIRC).
  40. International Integrated Reporting Council (2012a), Understanding Transformation: Building the Business Case for Integrated Reporting, retrieved 3 January 2017, -- from
  41. International Integrated Reporting Council (2012b), Pilot Programme Yearbook 2012, retrieved 3 January 2017, -- from
  42. International Integrated Reporting Committee (2011), Towards Integrated Reporting. Communicating Value in the 21th Century, retrieved 3 january 2017, -- from
  43. Integrated Reporting Committee of South Africa (2011), Framework for Integrated Reporting and the Integrated Report: Discussion paper’, retrieved 3 January 2017, -- from
  44. Jensen J. C., and Berg (2012), Determinants of traditional sustainability reporting versus integrated reporting. An institutionalist approach, Business Strategy and the Environment, 21(5), pp. 299-316,
  45. Jung N., and Kieser A. (2012), Consultants in the Management Fashion Arena, in M. Kipping, & T. Clark (Eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Management Consulting (New York: Oxford University Press),
  46. Kolk A., and Perego P. (2010), Determinants of the adoption of sustainability assurance statements: An international investigation, Business Strategy and the Environment, 19(3), pp. 182-198,
  47. KPMG (2013), Corporate responsibility reporting survey 2013, retrieved 1 January 2017, -- from au/en/issuesandinsights/articlespublications/ pages/corporate-responsibility-reportingsurvey-2013.aspx.
  48. KPMG (2012), Integrated Reporting: performance insight through better business reporting. Issue 2, retrieved 1 January 2017, -- from http://integratedreporting. org/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/KPMG-Integrated-Reporting-Performance-Insight-Through-Better-Business-Reporting-Issue-2.pdf.
  49. Lai A., Melloni G. and Stacchezzini R. (2016), Corporate sustainable development: is ‘integrated reporting’a legitimation strategy?, Business Strategy and the Environment, 25(3), pp. 165-177,
  50. Lee K. W., and Yeo G.H.H. (2016), The association between integrated reporting and firm valuation, Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting, 47(4), pp. 1221-1250,
  51. Lodhia S. (2015), Exploring the transition to integrated reporting through a practice lens: an Australian customer owned bank perspective, Journal of Business Ethics, 129(3), pp. 585-598,
  52. Lodhia S., and Hess N. (2014), Sustainability accounting and reporting in the mining industry: current literature and directions for future research, Journal of Cleaner Production, 84, pp. 43-50,
  53. Maniora J. (2015), Is integrated reporting really the superior mechanism for the integration of ethics into the core business model? An empirical analysis, Journal of Business Ethics, 140(4), pp. 755-786,
  54. March J. G. (1978), Bounded rationality, ambiguity and the engineering of choice, Bell Journal of Economics, 9, pp. 587-608, DOI: 10.2307/3003600
  55. Marx B., and Van Der Watt A. (2011), Sustainability and integrated reporting: an analysis of the audit committee’s oversight role, Journal for New Generation Sciences, 9(2), pp. 56-71.
  56. Melloni G. (2015), Intellectual capital disclosure in integrated reporting: an impression management analysis, Journal of Intellectual Capital, 16(3), pp. 661-680,
  57. Mio C., Marco F. and Pauluzzo R. (2016), Internal application of IR principles: Generali’s Internal Integrated Reporting, Journal of Cleaner Production, 139, pp. 204-218,
  58. Moberly R. E. (2007), Unfulfilled expectations: An empirical analysis of why Sarbanes-Oxley whistleblowers rarely win, Wm. and Mary L. Rev., 49, pp. 65.
  59. Perego P., Kennedy S. and Whiteman G. (2016), A lot of icing but little cake? Taking integrated reporting forward, Journal of Cleaner Production, 136, pp. 53-64,
  60. Reuter M., and Messner M. (2015), Lobbying on the integrated reporting framework: an analysis of comment letters to the 2011 discussion paper of the IIRC, Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal, 28(3), pp. 365-402,
  61. Rinaldi L., Unerman J. and De Villiers C. (2018), Evaluating the integrated reporting journey: insights, gaps and agendas for future research, Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, 31(5), pp. 1294-1318,
  62. Robertson F. A., and Samy M. (2015), Factors affecting the diffusion of integrated reporting – a UK FTSE 100 perspective, Sustainability Accounting, Management and Policy Journal, 6(2), pp. 190-223,
  63. Romano R. (2004), The Sarbanes-Oxley Act and the Making of Quack Corporate Governance, Working Paper, New York University Law and Economics.
  64. Sierra‐García L., Zorio‐Grima A. and García‐Benau M.A. (2015), Stakeholder engagement, corporate social responsibility and integrated reporting: an exploratory study, Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management, 22(5), pp. 286-304,
  65. Simnett R., and Huggins A.L. (2015), Integrated reporting and assurance: where can research add value?, Sustainability Accounting, Management and Policy Journal, 6(1), pp. 29-53,
  66. Steyn M. (2014), Organisational benefits and implementation challenges of mandatory integrated reporting: Perspectives of senior executives at South African listed companies, Sustainability Accounting, Management and Policy Journal, 5(4), pp. 476-503,
  67. Stent W., and Dowler T. (2015), Early assessments of the gap between integrated reporting and current corporate reporting, Meditari Accountancy Research, 23(1), pp. 92-117,
  68. Stubbs W., and Higgins C. (2014), Integrated reporting and internal mechanisms of change, Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal, 27(7), pp. 1068-1089,
  69. Suárez E., Calvo-Mora A., Roldán J.L. and Periáñez-Cristóbal R. (2017), Quantitative research on the EFQM excellence model: A systematic literature review (1991-2015), European Research on Management and Business Economics, 23(3), pp. 127-156,
  70. Suddaby R., Bitektine A. and Haack P. (2017). Legitimacy. Academy of Management Annals, 11(1), pp. 451-478,
  71. Sulkowski A. and Waddock S. (2012), Beyond Sustainability Reporting: Integrated Reporting Is Practiced, Required, and More Would Be Better, U. St. Thomas LJ, 10, pp. 1060,
  72. Sutton R. I. and Staw B.M. (1995), What theory is not, Administrative science quarterly, pp. 371-384, DOI: 10.2307/2393788
  73. Tweedie D. and Martinov-Bennie N. (2015), Entitlements and Time: Integrated Reporting’s Double-edged Agenda, Social and Environmental Accountability Journal, 35(1), pp. 49-61,
  74. Van Zyl A. S. (2013), Sustainability and integrated reporting in the South African corporate sector, Journal of Sustainability Management, 1(1), pp. 19,
  75. Velte P. and Stawinoga M. (2017), Integrated reporting: The current state of empirical research, limitations and future research implications, Journal of Management Control, 28(3), pp 275-320,
  76. Veltri S. and Silvestri A. (2015), The Free State University integrated reporting: a critical consideration, Journal of Intellectual Capital, 16(2), pp. 443-462,
  77. Wadee N. (2011), Integrated reporting–an opportunity to reshape business, Accountancy SA, 2587254, pp. 6.
  78. Wild S. and van Staden C. (2013), Integrated reporting: initial analysis of early reporters – an institutional theory approach, Conference presentation at the 7th Asia Pacific interdisciplinary accounting research conference, July.
  79. White A. (2010), The five capitals of integrated reporting: Toward a holistic architecture for corporate disclosure, The Landscape of Integrated Reporting. (Cambridge: Harvard Business School).
  80. Zhou S., Simnett R. & Green W. (2017), Does integrated reporting matter to the capital market?, Abacus, 53(1), pp. 94-132,

  • Differences in Disclosure of Integrated Reports at Energy and Non-Energy Companies Maja Piesiewicz, Marlena Ciechan-Kujawa, Paweł Kufel, in Energies /2021 pp.1253
    DOI: 10.3390/en14051253
  • Integrated Reporting and the experience of the Pilot Programme: perspective of an Italian pioneer company over ten years Palmira Piedepalumbo, Ludovica Evangelista, Daniela Mancini, Elisabetta Magnaghi, in Journal of Accounting & Organizational Change /2024
    DOI: 10.1108/JAOC-04-2023-0074

Brigitte de Graaff, Bert Steens, Kees Camfferman, Integrated reporting: Much ado about nothing? in "FINANCIAL REPORTING" 2/2021, pp 119-160, DOI: 10.3280/FR2021-002004