Is Epistemic Trust relevant for Vaccine Hesitancy? A study during the Covid-19 pandemic

Author/s Alice Fiorini Bincoletto, Filippo Maria Nimbi, Ginevra Protopapa, Vittorio Lingiardi, Guido Giovanardi
Publishing Year 2024 Issue 2024/1
Language English Pages 21 P. 46-66 File size 345 KB
DOI 10.3280/PDS2024-001003
DOI is like a bar code for intellectual property: to have more infomation click here

Below, you can see the article first page

If you want to buy this article in PDF format, you can do it, following the instructions to buy download credits

Article preview

FrancoAngeli is member of Publishers International Linking Association, Inc (PILA), a not-for-profit association which run the CrossRef service enabling links to and from online scholarly content.

Vaccine hesitancy and conspiracy beliefs are social issues of growing concern which have arisen particularly during the COVID-19 pandemic. The aim of this study was to investigate the multifaceted relationship between a hesitant attitude towards vaccination, conspiracy thinking, fear of infection, and the dimensions of epistemic trust, mistrust, and credulity. 297 Italian adult participants completed an online survey during the pan-demic time frame which included self-report questionnaires that measured the variables of interest. Group differences pertaining to prior vaccination behavior in scores of con-spiracy beliefs about vaccines and vaccine hesitancy were explored. A negative associa-tion was found between years of education and both vaccine hesitancy and conspiracy beliefs about vaccines, and a positive one with epistemic trust; higher education may protect the individual from misinformation and help in discerning between real knowledge and fake or imprecise news. A mediation model was developed between ep-istemic stance, vaccine conspiracy belief, vaccine hesitancy, and COVID-19-specific variables: the affective dimension (fear of contagion) and the behavioral one (number of vaccine doses). The model demonstrates how certain structural characteristics, such as epistemic credulity and skepticism towards vaccine benefits, may indirectly affect the number of COVID-19 vaccine doses taken through fear of contracting the virus. The re-sults support the value of exploring vaccine hesitancy and conspiracy beliefs in relation to epistemic trust dimensions, specifically in the post-pandemic era, and are discussed in light of the recent literature.

Keywords: vaccine hesitancy, conspiracy beliefs, covid-19, epistemic trust, epistemic mistrust, epistemic credulity

  1. Adhikari B., Yeong Cheah P. and von Seidlein L. (2022). Trust is the common denominator for COVID-19 vaccine acceptance: A literature review. Vaccine, X (12).
  2. Bruno F., Laganà V., Pistininzi R., Tarantino F., Martin L. and Servidio R. (2022). Validation and psychometric properties of the Italian Vaccination Attitudes Examination (VAX-I) scale. Current Psychology (New Brunswick, N.J.), 1-11.
  3. Callaghan T., Moghtaderi A., Lueck J.A., Hotez P., Strych U., Dor A., Fowler E.F. and Motta M. (2021). Correlates and disparities of intention to vaccinate against COVID-19. Social Science and Medicine, 272.
  4. Callender D. (2016). Vaccine hesitancy: More than a movement. Human Vaccines and Immunotherapeutics, 12 (9): 2464–2468. DOI: 10.1080/21645515.2016.1178434
  5. Campbell C., Tanzer M., Saunders R., Booker T., Allison E., Li E., O’Dowda C., Luyten P. and Fonagy P. (2021). Development and validation of a self-report measure of epistemic trust. PLoS ONE, 16 (4): e0250264.
  6. Čavojová V., Šrol J. and Ballová Mikušková E. (2022). How scientific reasoning correlates with health-related beliefs and behaviors during the COVID-19 pandemic? Journal of Health Psychology, 27 (3): 534–547. DOI: 10.1177/1359105320962266
  7. Csibra G. and Gergely G. (2009). Natural pedagogy. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 13 (4): 148–153.
  8. Douglas K. M., Sutton R. M., Callan M. J., Dawtry R. J. and Harvey A. J. (2016). Someone is pulling the strings: hypersensitive agency detection and belief in conspiracy theories. Thinking and Reasoning, 22 (1): 57-77. DOI: 10.1080/13546783.2015.1051586
  9. Dubé E., Gagnon D., MacDonald N., Bocquier A., Peretti-Watel P. and Verger P. (2018). Underlying factors impacting vaccine hesitancy in high income countries: a review of qualitative studies. Expert Review of Vaccines, 17 (11): 989-1004. DOI: 10.1080/14760584.2018.1541406
  10. Lewandowsky S., Gignac G.E. and Oberauer K. (2013). The Role of Conspiracist Ideation and Worldviews in Predicting Rejection of Science. PLoS ONE, 8 (10): e0134773.
  11. Dubé E., Vivion M. and MacDonald N.E. (2014). Vaccine hesitancy, vaccine refusal and the anti-vaccine movement: Influence, impact and implications. Expert Review of Vaccines, 14 (1): 99–117. DOI: 10.1586/14760584.2015.964212
  12. Dyrendal A., Kennair L.E.O. and Bendixen M. (2021). Predictors of belief in conspiracy theory: The role of individual differences in schizotypal traits, paranormal beliefs, social dominance orientation, right wing authoritarianism and conspiracy mentality. Personality and Individual Differences, 173.
  13. Fiorini Bincoletto A., Zanini L., Spitoni G.F. and Lingiardi V. (2023). Negative and positive ageism in an Italian sample: how ageist beliefs relate to epistemic trust, psychological distress, and well-being. Research in psychotherapy, 26 (2): 676.
  14. Fischer D.G. and Fick C. (1993). Measuring social desirability: Short forms of the Marlowe-Crowne social desirability scale. Educational and Psychological Measurement, 53 (2): 417-424. DOI: 10.1177/0013164493053002011
  15. Fitzpatrick K.M., Harris C. and Drawve G. (2020). Fear of COVID-19 and the mental health consequences in America. Psychological Trauma: Theory, Research, Practice, and Policy, 12 (S1): S17–S21.
  16. Fonagy P. and Allison E. (2014). The role of mentalizing and epistemic trust in the therapeutic relationship. Psychotherapy, 51 (3): 372–380.
  17. Fonagy P. and Campbell C. (2021). Future directions in personality pathology. Current Opinion in Psychology, 37: 145–151.
  18. Gerhold L. (2020, March 25). COVID-19: Risk perception and Coping strategies.
  19. Giovanardi G., Fiorini Bincoletto A., Baiocco R., Ferrari M., Gentile D., Siri M., Tanzilli A. and Lingiardi V. (2021). Lockdown Dreams: Dream Content and Emotions During the COVID-19 Pandemic in an Italian Sample. Psychoanalytic Psychology, 39 (2): 111–126.
  20. Hornsey M.J., Harris E.A. and Fielding K.S. (2018). The psychological roots of anti-vaccination attitudes: A 24-nation investigation. Health Psychology, 37 (4): 307-315.
  21. Imhoff R. and Bruder M. (2014). Speaking (Un-)truth to power: Conspiracy mentality as a generalised political attitude. European Journal of Personality, 28 (1): 25-43.
  22. Imhoff R., Lamberty P. and Klein O. (2018). Using Power as a Negative Cue: How Conspiracy Mentality Affects Epistemic Trust in Sources of Historical Knowledge. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 44 (9): 1364–1379. DOI: 10.1177/0146167218768779
  23. Jacobi C.J. and Vaidyanathan B. (2021). Racial differences in anticipated COVID-19 vaccine acceptance among religious populations in the US. Vaccine, 39 (43): 6351–6355.
  24. Jolley D. and Douglas K.M. (2017). Prevention is better than cure: Addressing anti-vaccine conspiracy theories. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 47 (8): 459–469.
  25. Kalichma S.C. (2009). Denying AIDS: Conspiracy theories, pseudoscience, and human tragedy. New York: Springer.
  26. Larson H.J., Jarrett C., Eckersberger E., Smith D.M.D. and Paterson P. (2014). Understanding vaccine hesitancy around vaccines and vaccination from a global perspective: A systematic review of published literature, 2007-2012. Vaccine, 32 (19): 2150–2159.
  27. Latkin C.A., Dayton L., Yi G., Konstantopoulos A. and Boodram B. (2021). Trust in a COVID-19 vaccine in the U.S.: A social-ecological perspective. Social Science and Medicine, 270: 113684.
  28. Lazarus J.V., Wyka K., White T.M., Picchio C.A., Rabin K., Ratzan S.C., Parsons Leigh J., Hu J. and El-Mohandes A. (2022). Revisiting COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy around the world using data from 23 countries in 2021. Nature Communications, 13 (1): 3801.
  29. Liotti M., Milesi A., Spitoni G.F., Tanzilli A., Speranza A.M., Parolin L., Campbell C., Fonagy P., Lingiardi V. and Giovanardi G. (2023). Unpacking trust: The Italian validation of the Epistemic Trust, Mistrust, and Credulity Questionnaire (ETMCQ). PLoS ONE, 18 (1): e0280328.
  30. Maciuszek J., Polak M., Stasiuk K. and Rosiński J. (2023). Declared Intention to Vaccinate against COVID-19 and Actual Vaccination—The Role of Trust in Science, Conspiratorial Thinking and Religiosity. Vaccines, 11 (2): 262.
  31. Manganelli Rattazzi A.M., Canova L. and Marcorin R. (2000). La desiderabilità sociale. Un’analisi di forme brevi della scala di Marlow e Crowne [Social desirability. Analysis of a short version of Marlow & Crowne’s scale]. Testing Psicometria Metodologia (TPM), 7: 5–17.
  32. Martin L.R. and Petrie K.J. (2017). Understanding the Dimensions of Anti-Vaccination Attitudes: The Vaccination Attitudes Examination (VAX) Scale. Annals of behavioral medicine: a publication of the Society of Behavioral Medicine, 51 (5): 652–660.
  33. Nasralah T., Elnoshokaty A., El-Gayar O., Al-Ramahi M. and Wahbeh A. (2022). A comparative analysis of anti-vax discourse on twitter before and after COVID-19 onset. Health Informatics Journal, 28 (4): 14604582221135831. DOI: 10.1177/14604582221135831
  34. Nimbi F.M., Baiocco R., Giovanardi G., Tanzilli A. and Lingiardi V. (2023). Who Is Afraid of Monkeypox? Analysis of Psychosocial Factors Associated with the First Reactions of Fear of Monkeypox in the Italian Population. Behavioral Sciences, 13 (3): 235.
  35. Nimbi F.M., Giovanardi G., Baiocco R., Tanzilli A. and Lingiardi V. (2023). Monkeypox: New epidemic or fake news? Study of psychological and social factors associated with fake news attitudes of monkeypox in Italy. Frontiers in Psychology, 14: 1093763.
  36. Nyhan B. and Reifler J. (2015). Does correcting myths about the flu vaccine work? An experimental evaluation of the effects of corrective information. Vaccine, 33 (3): 459–464.
  37. Nyhan B., Reifler J., Richey S. and Freed G.L. (2014). Effective messages in vaccine promotion: A randomized trial. Pediatrics, 133 (4): e835–e842.
  38. Oliver J.E. and Wood T.J. (2014). Conspiracy theories and the paranoid style(s) of mass opinion. American Journal of Political Science, 58 (4): 952-966.
  39. Pakpour A.H. and Griffiths M.D. (2020). The fear of COVID-19 and its role in preventive behaviours. Journal of Concurrent Disorders, 2 (1): 58-63.
  40. Peretti-Watel P., Larson H.J., Ward J.K., Schulz W.S. and Verger P. (2015). Vaccine hesitancy: Clarifying a theoretical framework for an ambiguous notion. PLoS Currents, 7.
  41. Pierre J.M. (2020). Mistrust and misinformation: A two-component, socio-epistemic model of belief in conspiracy theories. Journal of Social and Political Psychology, 8 (2).
  42. Roozenbeek J., Schneider C.R., Dryhurst S., Kerr J., Freeman A.L.J., Recchia G., Van Der Bles A.M. and Van Der Linden S. (2020). Susceptibility to misinformation about COVID-19 around the world: Susceptibility to COVID misinformation. Royal Society Open Science, 7 (10): 201199.
  43. Sekizawa Y., Hashimoto S., Denda K., Ochi S. and So M. (2022). Association between COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy and generalized trust, depression, generalized anxiety, and fear of COVID-19. BMC Public Health, 22 (1): 126.
  44. Shapiro G.K., Holding A., Perez S., Amsel R. and Rosberger Z. (2016). Validation of the vaccine conspiracy beliefs scale. Papillomavirus Research, 2: 167–172.
  45. Sperber D., Clément F., Heintz C., Mascaro O., Mercier H., Origgi G. and Wilson D. (2010). Epistemic vigilance. Mind and Language, 25 (4): 359–393.
  46. Šrol J., Ballová Mikušková E. and Čavojová V. (2021). When we are worried, what are we thinking? Anxiety, lack of control, and conspiracy beliefs amidst the COVID-19 pandemic. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 35 (3): 720–729.
  47. Stojanovic J., Boucher V.G., Gagne M., Gupta S., Joyal-Desmarais K., Paduano S., Aburub A.S., Sheinfeld Gorin S.N., Kassianos A.P., Ribeiro P.A.B., Bacon S.L. and Lavoie K.L. (2021). Global trends and correlates of covid-19 vaccination hesitancy: Findings from the icare study. Vaccines, 9 (6): 661.
  48. Stroope S., Kroeger R. A., Williams C.E. and Baker J.O. (2021). Sociodemographic correlates of vaccine hesitancy in the United States and the mediating role of beliefs about governmental conspiracies. Social Science Quarterly, 102 (6): 2472-2481.
  49. Tanzer M., Campbell C., Saunders R., Luyten P., Booker T. and Fonagy P. (2021). Acquiring knowledge: Epistemic trust in the age of fake news.
  50. Tanzilli A., Cibelli A., Liotti M., Fiorentino F., Williams R. and Lingiardi V. (2022). Personality, Defenses, Mentalization, and Epistemic Trust Related to Pandemic Containment Strategies and the COVID-19 Vaccine: A Sequential Mediation Model. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 19 (21): 14290.
  51. Viswanath K., Bekalu M., Dhawan D., Pinnamaneni R., Lang J. and McLoud R. (2021). Individual and social determinants of COVID-19 vaccine uptake. BMC Public Health, 21 (1): 818.
  52. Vulpe S.N. and Rughiniş C. (2021). Social amplification of risk and “probable vaccine damage”: A typology of vaccination beliefs in 28 European countries. Vaccine, 39 (10): 1508-1515.
  53. Wang Y. and Liu Y. (2022). Multilevel determinants of COVID-19 vaccination hesitancy in the United States: A rapid systematic review. Preventive Medicine Reports, 25: 101673.
  54. World Health Organization (2013). Retrieved from: vac-cine-action-plan-2011-2020.
  55. Xu T. and Sattar U. (2020). Conceptualizing covid-19 and public panic with the moderating role of media use and uncertainty in china: An empirical framework. Healthcare (Switzerland), 8 (3), 249.
  56. Zimmerman R.K., Wolfe R.M., Fox D.E., Fox J.R., Nowalk M.P., Troy J.A. and Sharp L.K. (2005). Vaccine criticism on the world wide web. Journal of Medical Internet Research, 7 (2): e17.
  57. Zimmerman T., Shiroma K., Fleischmann K.R., Xie B., Jia C., Verma N. and Lee M.K. (2023). Misinformation and COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy. Vaccine, 41 (1): 136–144.

  • No more than “half prevention”: A qualitative study on psychosocial determinants of Covid-19 vaccination acceptance Miriam Capasso, Maria Florencia González Leone, Marcella Bianchi, Federica Mari, Daniela Caso, in Acta Psychologica 104406/2024 pp.104406
    DOI: 10.1016/j.actpsy.2024.104406

Alice Fiorini Bincoletto, Filippo Maria Nimbi, Ginevra Protopapa, Vittorio Lingiardi, Guido Giovanardi, Is Epistemic Trust relevant for Vaccine Hesitancy? A study during the Covid-19 pandemic in "PSICOLOGIA DELLA SALUTE" 1/2024, pp 46-66, DOI: 10.3280/PDS2024-001003