Dall’origine della superstizione all’origine del movimento: lo strano caso della confutazione tolandiana di Spinoza

Journal title RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA
Author/s Andrea Sangiacomo
Publishing Year 2013 Issue 2013/4
Language Italian Pages 27 P. 645-671 File size 534 KB
DOI 10.3280/SF2013-004001
DOI is like a bar code for intellectual property: to have more infomation click here

Article preview

FrancoAngeli is member of Publishers International Linking Association, Inc (PILA), a not-for-profit association which run the CrossRef service enabling links to and from online scholarly content.

Toland’s Letters to Serena proposes a confutation of Spinoza that is rather puzzling. Apparently, the theme of the confutation, which discusses the cause of movement and the activity of matter, is not linked with previous letters addressing the genealogy of religious prejudice. Moreover, the confutation as such seems grounded on a misunderstanding of Spinoza’s position. This paper aims to show that Toland’s attitude towards Spinoza can be better understood by considering it against the background of seventeenth-century debates on secondary causation and Occasionalism. First, I will show the continuity between the first three letters concerning prejudices and the confutation of Spinoza. Second, I will argue that Toland’s confutation as such is philologically mistaken and Spinoza himself may have been in sympathy with Toland’s own position on the activity of matter. Third, I suggest that Toland’s way of framing the entire discussion is deeply influenced by his attempt to counter a precise argument against body-body causation formulated by Louis de La Forge and reproduced by Antoine Le Grand. According to Toland, this Occasionalistic perspective has dangerous ethical- political consequences that Spinoza’s ontology is unable to deal with.

Keywords: Toland, Spinoza, Occasionalism, causality, activity of matter, La Forge, Le Grand.

  1. Boyle 1999-2000: Robert Boyle, The Works of Robert Boyle, edited by Michael Hunter and Edward B. Davis, 14 voll., Pichering and Chatto, London 1999-2000.
  2. Clarke 1705: Samuel Clarke, A Demonstration of the Being and Attributes of God. More particularly in Answer to Mr. Hobbes, Spinoza and their Followers, William Botham for James Knapton, London 1705.
  3. Descartes 1964-1974: René Descartes, Oeuvres a cura di Charles Adam e Paul Tannery, nuova presentazione di Joseph Beaude, Pierre Costabel, Alan Gabbey e Bernard Rochot, 11 voll., Paris: Vrin, 1964-1974.
  4. Hobbes 1999: Thomas Hobbes, De Corpore. Elementorum Philosophiae Sectio Prima, édition critique, notes, appendice et index par Karl Schuhmann, Vrin, Paris 1999.
  5. Fontenelle 1892: Bernard le Bovier de Fontenelle, OEuvres de Fontenelle, chez Jean-François Bastien, Paris 1892.
  6. La Forge 1974: Louis de La Forge, OEuvres Philosophiques, avec une étude bio-bibliographique, édition présentée par Pierre Clair, Puf, Paris 1974.
  7. Le Grand 1694: Antoine Le Grand, Entire Body of Philosophy according to the Principles of the Famous Renates des Cartes, by Richard Blome, London 1694.
  8. - Leibniz 2006: Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, Philosophischer Briefewechsel, herausgegeben von der Leibniz-Forschungsstelle der Universität Munster, Erster Band, 1663- 1685, Zweite, neuberarbeitete und erweiterte Auflage, 2006.
  9. Malebranche 1991: Nicolas Malebranche, Recherche de la vérité, où l’on traite de la nature de l’esprit de l’homme et de l’usage qu’il en doit faire pour éviter l’erreur dans les sciences, édité par Geneviève Rodis-Lewis [avec la collaboration de Pierre Clair], Vrin, Paris 1991.
  10. - Régis 1691: Pierre-Sylvain Régis, Cours entier de philosophie, ou Systeme general selon les principes de M. Descartes, aux depens des Huguetan, Amsterdam 1691.
  11. Regius 1654: Henricus Regius, Philosophia Naturalis, Apud Ludovicum Elzevirium, Amsterdam 1654.
  12. Spinoza 20112: Baruch Spinoza, Tutte le opere, a cura di Andrea Sangiacomo, Bompiani, Milano 20112.
  13. Toland 1704: John Toland, Letters to Serena, Bernard Linton, London 1704.
  14. Toland 2002: Id., Opere, a cura di Chiara Giuntini, Utet, Torino 2002.
  15. Wotton 1704: John Wotton, A letter to Eusebia: Occasioned by Mr. Toland’s Letters to Serena, Tim Goodwin, London 1704.
  16. Breschi 2012: Danilo Breschi, Storia intellettuale o filosofia della storia? L’illuminismo radicale secondo Jonathan Israel, «Filosofia Politica», XXVI (2012), 3, pp. 483-488.
  17. Busse 2009: Julien Busse, Le problème de l’essence de l’homme chez Spinoza, Pups, Paris 2009.
  18. Casini 1969: Paolo Casini, L’universo-macchina. Origini della filosofia newtoniana, Laterza, Roma-Bari 1969.
  19. Clatterbaugh 1999: Kenneth Clatterbaugh, The causation debate in modern philosophy, 1637-1739, Routledge, New York 1999.
  20. Colie 1959: Rosmarie L. Colie, Spinoza and the English Deists, «Journal of the History of Ideas», XX (1959), 1, pp. 23-46.
  21. Duncan 2012: Stewart Duncan, Toland, Leibniz and Active Matter, «Oxford Studies in Early Modern Philosophy», VI (2012), pp. 249-278.
  22. Dagron 2009: Tristan Dagron, Toland et Leibniz. L’invention du Néo-spinozisme, Vrin, Paris 2009.
  23. Deleuze 1968: Gilles Deleuze, Spinoza et le problème de l’expression, Editions de Minuit, Paris 1968.
  24. Garber 1987: Daniel Garber, How God causes motion: Descartes, divine sustenance, and Occasionalism, «Journal of Philosophy», LXXXIV (1987), 10, pp. 567-580.
  25. Giuntini 2000: Chiara Giuntini, Le fonti di Toland, in Santucci 2000, pp. 295-316.
  26. Iofrida 1983: Manlio Iofrida, La filosofia di John Toland. Spinozismo, scienza e religione nella cultura europea fra ‘600 e ‘700, Angeli, Milano 1983.
  27. Israel 2005: Jonathan Israel, Les Lumières Radicales (trad. fr.), Amsterdam, Paris 2005 (ed. originale Oxford UP, Oxford 2001).
  28. Jacob 1969: Margaret C. Jacob, Toland and the Newtonian Ideology, «Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes», XXXII (1969), pp. 307-333.
  29. Jaquet 2005: Chantal Jaquet, Les expressions de la puissance d’agir chez Spinoza, Pups, Paris 2005.
  30. Leask 2012: Ian Leask, Unholy Force: Toland’s Leibnizian ‘Consummation’ of Spinozism, «British Journal for the History of Philosophy», XX (2012), 3, pp. 499-537.
  31. Leijenhorst 2002: Cees Leijenhorst, The mechanisation of Aristotelianism. The late Aristotelian setting of Thomas Hobbes’ natural philosophy, Brill, Leiden 2002.

  • Encyclopedia of Early Modern Philosophy and the Sciences Andrea Sangiacomo, pp.1576 (ISBN:978-3-319-31067-1)
  • Louis de La Forge and the ‘Non-Transfer Argument’ for Occasionalism Andrea Sangiacomo, in British Journal for the History of Philosophy /2014 pp.60
    DOI: 10.1080/09608788.2013.866071
  • Encyclopedia of Early Modern Philosophy and the Sciences Andrea Sangiacomo, pp.1 (ISBN:978-3-319-20791-9)

Andrea Sangiacomo, Dall’origine della superstizione all’origine del movimento: lo strano caso della confutazione tolandiana di Spinoza in "RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA" 4/2013, pp 645-671, DOI: 10.3280/SF2013-004001